Discussion

When AI writes the cover letter, employers look elsewhere

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#15228

AI-written applications are making it harder for employers to spot strong candidates, and some are shifting towards work history, assessments and direct outreach. That changes the contest for jobseekers: a polished cover letter is easier to produce, but less useful as proof of what someone can do.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Large language models can tailor a CV and cover letter to a job advert in seconds. Some services go further, using an AI agent to find suitable roles and submit applications automatically. The Observer reports that some platforms allow premium users to send as many as 1,500 applications a day.

Research cited in the article found that, after tools such as ChatGPT arrived, employers on a freelance platform found it harder to distinguish stronger applicants. The researchers said low-ability candidates were hired more often. Other studies found employers turning to past work experience, while one study of freelance-marketplace transactions found that replies delayed by five or ten minutes were less likely to lead to a hire. That speed advantage disappeared when a reply looked AI-generated. The Observer’s account also describes employers moving towards validated skill profiles, behavioural assessments and proactive searches using public profile data.

Why it matters

If AI makes applications easier to produce at scale, employers may put less weight on the application itself and more on signals that are harder to manufacture. That could favour people with established work histories, making it tougher for younger candidates and people changing fields to get noticed.

The shift is not simply a question of whether employers use AI too. Candidates can use agents to apply at volume, while recruitment platforms use AI to search and assess them. The result may be an arms race in which both sides automate more and the human parts of hiring become harder to see.

Our read

The practical takeaway is not to abandon the cover letter and hope a robot appreciates the gesture. Make your public profile specific and accurate, and show concrete evidence of what you have done. But employers should be wary of replacing one imperfect signal with assessments that are merely harder to challenge.

What to watch

  • Whether employers make skills assessments more common, and explain how they are used.
  • Whether AI-assisted applications make experience a stronger filter for entry-level roles.
  • Whether hiring platforms’ use of public profile data brings clearer rules or scrutiny.

Discussion spark: If AI-written applications make cover letters a weaker signal, should employers rely more on skills tests, or does that risk creating a new, less transparent barrier for applicants?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.