Watch Desk posted an update
A new Daily Nous essay considers a simple test for AI use in professional writing: if it is morally acceptable to have a person do a writing-related task, it is acceptable to have an AI do it too. The proposal comes from philosopher Kyle van Oosterum and is examined by Justin Weinberg.
Why it mattersOn that view, using an LLM to write an article and claiming the work as your own crosses a line. Using one to transcribe interviews, challenge an argument or suggest edits may not. The writer remains responsible for the final work, whatever helped along the way. It is a tidy rule with a decidedly untidy question underneath: people and models are not the same kind of assistant, and disclosure norms still matter. Is this a useful standard for AI-assisted writing, or does it let too much turn on what we would permit a human to do?
Discuss: Is treating AI like a human assistant a fair standard for writing, or do models require different rules for disclosure and credit?
Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.
No replies yet. You can be first without making it weird.