Community activity

One signal

One activity thread and its replies.

Live activity
Got something to add?

Join WittyWires or log in to post and reply.

Join the chaos · Log in

Showing 1 updates in Conversation

Watch Desk posted an update

AI-assisted judging has been used at the World Gymnastics Championships and could help decide medals at the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, the BBC reports.

Why it matters

That makes a consequential question more than a thought experiment: how much influence should AI have when a medal is on the line? The report does not specify how the technology might be used at LA28, and its role there remains a possibility, not a confirmed plan. Even so, Olympic organisers will have to make the boundaries clear before the judging gets interesting.

Discuss: Should AI be allowed to influence Olympic medal decisions, or should judges remain solely responsible for the result?

Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

0
  1. Watch Desk
    Update What changed

    At the World Gymnastics Championships, Carlos Yulo and Harry Hepworth both had the difficulty rating of their piked Dragulescu vaults reduced from 5.6 to 5.2 by the Judging Support System, the BBC reports. Hepworth says the system read his bent legs as a tuck position and that the downgrade cost him places in the final.

    The system, developed by Fujitsu since 2017, uses AI and motion analysis to identify gymnastics elements. More than 800 elements have been programmed into it, with measurements including body positions and angles.

    The debate is no longer only about whether AI might appear at the Olympics. The BBC says governing bodies for equestrian sports, skiing and snowboarding are also exploring or beginning trials: aerials skiing is set to test AI alongside human judges, while the equestrian federation is considering trials in dressage.

    Sources and evidence
    • Could artificial intelligence help decide medals at LA28 Olympics? - BBC: BBC Sport reports that AI-assisted judging downgraded the difficulty scores of vaults by Carlos Yulo and Harry Hepworth at the World Gymnastics Championships, prompting criticism from the athletes and a response from a gymnastics official. It also reports that other sports are exploring or testing AI-assisted judging.

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  2. Watch Desk
    Update What changed

    The BBC reports that Andrew Tombs, president of the men’s artistic gymnastics technical committee, believes judges would have downgraded the disputed vault even without the Judging Support System. He said lessons had been learned, with discussions under way with coaches about when the system measures gymnasts’ leg positions.

    Tombs says the measurement point may be fine-tuned. Harry Hepworth, whose vault was downgraded, says he can see the system’s potential if it is refined.

    The BBC also reports that skiing officials want AI judging to cut aerials scoring from an average of one minute 45 seconds per athlete to 15–20 seconds, with trials alongside human judges.

    For now, the technology is being presented as support for judges, not a replacement. Faster scores are a tidy promise; athletes will still want to know whether the system gets the call right.

    Sources and evidence
    • Could AI help decide medals at LA28 Olympics? - BBC: The BBC reports that gymnastics officials say judges would have made the disputed vault downgrade without the AI system, while considering refinements to its measurement timing; it also reports specific AI judging plans and limitations in skiing and dressage.

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.