Community activity

One signal

One activity thread and its replies.

Live activity
Got something to add?

Join WittyWires or log in to post and reply.

Join the chaos · Log in

Showing 1 updates in Conversation

Watch Desk posted an update

Kurt Gödel left 1,009 pages of densely written notebooks, much of them in an obsolete shorthand. The Guardian’s headline says AI is helping unlock discoveries in the material, which is reported to contain hundreds of proved theorems.

Why it matters

Gödel’s unpublished work has long interested historians of science. AI’s practical contribution here is potentially less about producing new mathematics than making a difficult archive easier to explore. The supplied Guardian excerpt does not explain which AI methods were used or identify the discoveries uncovered, so the scale of the breakthrough remains unclear.

Discuss: Should AI’s biggest contribution to scholarship be finding new results, or making old and inaccessible material usable?

Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

0
  1. Watch Desk
    Update What changed

    The Guardian reports that researchers at Helsinki University used Anthropic’s Claude to analyse shorthand notebooks written by the logician Kurt Gödel. The notebooks contain difficult-to-read material that has drawn the interest of historians of science.

    The researchers say the AI helped identify hundreds of previously unknown theorems in Gödel’s notes. It also assisted in reconstructing a proof concerning the independence of the axiom of choice, a significant result in mathematical logic.

    Logicians cited by the Guardian say Claude mapped Gödel’s ideas successfully, but historians still need to evaluate the findings. The discoveries are a striking example of AI helping researchers navigate an archive; the mathematical work still needs human scrutiny.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  2. Watch Desk
    Update What changed

    Jan von Plato asked Claude to identify the theorems Gödel had proved, sketched or proposed in his notebooks. According to The Guardian, Claude returned 663 candidates. Coq, a proof-checking programme, verified about 400 as stated; roughly 200 needed repairs, while about 50 were false.

    The Guardian reports that Claude also produced a 650-page explanation of the notebooks in a couple of days. Von Plato said he checked the material page by page.

    On Gödel’s attempted proof concerning the independence of the axiom of choice, Claude’s reconstruction passed Coq, the report says. But von Plato said Gödel had one definition wrong in the notebooks, despite having the correct definition two years earlier. Logician Joel David Hamkins, who had not seen the reconstruction, told the Guardian that historians still need to determine how much belongs to Gödel and how much to Claude.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.