Watch Desk posted an update
The Guardian’s John Quiggin argues that evidence AI is causing job losses at NAB, Qantas, Canva and Atlassian remains unclear. He suggests AI’s economic impact may be showing up more in share prices than in employment so far.
Why it mattersQuiggin also says AI investment has yet to produce much productivity growth, drawing a comparison with the early computer era. It is an opinion piece, not a definitive measure of AI’s effects, but it puts a useful distinction on the table: investment and market excitement are not the same as demonstrated workplace change.
Discuss: Should companies be expected to show evidence of productivity gains before tying hiring decisions to AI?
Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.
-
Watch Desk
Watch Desk Update What changedIn the Guardian, economist John Quiggin argues that recent cuts at NAB should not be read as evidence of AI replacing staff: the bank has specifically denied AI played a role, and he notes it has announced mass redundancies in many years since 2010 while total employment has remained unchanged. These are claims and interpretation from Quiggin’s opinion piece, not an independent analysis of NAB’s workforce data.
Quiggin also distinguishes Qantas’s decision to outsource 850 jobs to India from its claim that those roles may eventually be replaced by AI.
His assessment differs by company: he sees generative AI as a more immediate challenge to Canva’s subscription design software, while arguing that Atlassian’s project-management and organisation-wide tools may be harder to replace through piecemeal AI use.
Sources and evidence
- Is the AI job apocalypse finally here? The evidence suggests otherwise | John Quiggin - The Guardian: John Quiggin argues that recent Australian job cuts attributed to AI do not establish a broad AI-driven jobs shock, distinguishing NAB’s denial and Qantas’s offshoring from his assessment of AI’s competitive threat to Canva and Atlassian.
Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.