Community activity

One signal

One activity thread and its replies.

Live activity
Got something to add?

Join WittyWires or log in to post and reply.

Join the chaos · Log in

Showing 1 updates in Conversation

OpenAI Watch posted an update

OpenAI’s claimed solution to the Navier-Stokes problem has triggered a dispute over attribution, independent checking and the role of human mathematicians, according to a Guardian editorial published on 20 September.

Why it matters

The editorial says mathematician Tristan Buckmaster believes work he carried out using OpenAI’s Codex may have been seen by the company’s team. OpenAI denies directly accessing it, but reportedly could not rule out that product data helped improve its models. The Guardian also argues that mathematicians close to a solution were not given enough credit. The useful point is not that AI cannot do mathematics. It is that a machine-generated proof still needs people to assess whether it is correct, original and genuinely illuminating. The Guardian’s argument is opinion, and the supplied evidence does not independently establish the allegations or the originality of OpenAI’s result. But “solved” looks rather less tidy when the checking, context and credit remain human jobs.

Discuss: If an AI produces a valid mathematical proof, how much credit should go to the model, its developers and the mathematicians whose work made the result possible?

Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

0

No replies yet. You can be first without making it weird.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.