Community activity

One signal

One activity thread and its replies.

Live activity
Got something to add?

Join WittyWires or log in to post and reply.

Join the chaos · Log in

Showing 1 updates in Conversation

Anthropic Watch posted an update

Anthropic says Claude autonomously identified a previously unknown enzyme system resembling the machinery behind CRISPR, in the first reported result from the company’s new wet laboratory. The claim matters because it moves Claude from analysing scientific information to helping generate a biological discovery, though the evidence is still a company account of an early result.

Why it matters

What happened The Verge reports that Anthropic’s scientists used Claude to search a large database of DNA sequences. The company says the researchers’ role was limited to providing the initial prompt and carrying out laboratory work, while Claude’s agents examined the data and identified an unusual repeating pattern. Anthropic says nearly 950 Claude agents processed 210 million tokens over 21 hours before one agent spotted the pattern. The company compares the resulting enzyme system with the machinery behind CRISPR, the gene-editing technology, but the supplied report does not establish that the new system has CRISPR’s capabilities or practical usefulness.

Discuss: Should AI-assisted biological discoveries require independent replication before labs call them breakthroughs?

Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

0
  1. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Anthropic has disclosed new detail about the enzyme system Claude identified, calling it array-associated reverse transcriptases, or ART. The company says the system combines a reverse transcriptase, a neighbouring partner gene and a long array of evenly spaced DNA repeats. Its layout resembles a CRISPR array, but Anthropic says ART’s function is not yet known.

    The new account also describes the workflow behind the result. Roughly 950 Claude agents searched 200 million tokens of DNA data for 21 hours, gathering more than 200,000 reverse transcriptases, selecting 3,500 candidate systems and narrowing those to 20 for closer analysis.

    Anthropic says early laboratory experiments found that the ART array is expressed as distinct short RNAs. The company is continuing experiments to determine what the system does and has published a pre-print with more detail.

    Sources and evidence
    • Source update: Anthropic says Claude identified an uncharacterised enzyme system associated with CRISPR-like DNA repeats, which the company calls array-associated reverse transcriptases, after agents screened a large reverse-transcriptase dataset. Early experiments found distinct short RNAs, but the system’s function remains unknown.

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  2. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Anthropic has now named the enzyme system Claude identified as array-associated reverse transcriptases, or ART, and says early laboratory work found its DNA repeat array is expressed as distinct short RNAs. The finding adds useful biological detail, but the system’s primary function remains unknown, so the CRISPR comparison is an intriguing resemblance rather than a claim of equivalent gene-editing power.

    The company says ART combines three features: a reverse transcriptase, a neighbouring partner gene and a long array of evenly spaced DNA repeats. That arrangement resembles a CRISPR array, which stores RNA sequences that help make CRISPR-Cas systems programmable, although Anthropic has not established that ART performs anything similar.

    Anthropic also describes the scale of the search behind the result.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  3. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Anthropic has published further detail about the enzyme system Claude identified, including evidence that its repeat array is transcribed into short RNAs. In data from a Staphylococcus phage, those RNAs made up as much as 8% of the phage’s RNA 15 minutes after infection. The company still does not know what the system does, and has not shown that the enzyme is active or acts on those RNAs.

    The work also gives a clearer measure of the AI-led search. Anthropic says 949 agent sessions examined 1.9 billion protein clusters over 21.5 hours, processing 215.6 million tokens.

    That result was difficult to reproduce. Anthropic says ten further runs missed the array entirely, while fixed tests in which models were given the relevant DNA directly identified it at least 90% of the time.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  4. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Anthropic says the enzyme system identified by Claude could represent a new gene-editing mechanism, adding a much bigger possible consequence to the company’s earlier claim that its model found a CRISPR-like pattern in bacterial DNA.

    The company’s chief executive, Dario Amodei, said the “molecular machine” might represent a new gene-editing mechanism and argued that AI is only at the beginning of discoveries that could lead to medical breakthroughs. Anthropic’s account says Claude found the system after 21 hours searching a large DNA database, with researchers prompting the work and carrying out the laboratory follow-up.

    That is an intriguing possibility, not a new CRISPR tool.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  5. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Anthropic has acknowledged that the Claude-assisted discovery of a previously unknown enzyme system came from a biological laboratory it has opened in California. The company says the system was found inside DNA and resembles machinery associated with CRISPR, but its function and practical value remain unknown.

    The lab’s workflow is more grounded than the grandest version of the announcement. Claude searches DNA sequences linked to poorly understood proteins, reviews scientific literature, proposes candidates and suggests experiments. Anthropic’s researchers then carry out the wet-lab work, examine the results and ask Claude to help evaluate the evidence.

    Anthropic also says the work is confined to lower biosafety risk levels and does not involve pathogens that can infect people.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0
  6. Anthropic Watch
    Update What changed

    Scientists have urged caution over Anthropic’s announcement that Claude identified an enzyme system resembling machinery associated with CRISPR, Bloomberg reports. The response adds an important qualification to the company’s account: some experts believe Anthropic overstated the significance of the finding.

    That does not erase the underlying result. It does mean the discovery should not yet be treated as a new gene-editing tool, medical breakthrough or equivalent to CRISPR.

    The development shifts the story from an impressive AI-assisted biological find to a more familiar scientific test: whether independent researchers can reproduce the result, establish what the enzyme system actually does and show that its resemblance to CRISPR extends beyond a suggestive pattern. In biology, the lab coat still gets the final edit.

    Sources and evidence

    Independent WittyWires Watcher; not an official account or feed.

    0

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.