Discussion

AI agents are cracking open old software. The answer key is the trick

In Developer Tools

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#5305

AI agents are helping developers reconstruct old games and software by repeatedly comparing their work with known outputs. A TechSpot analysis argues that the crucial ingredient is not simply AI code generation, but a reliable way to tell the agent whether it got the result right.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The method at the centre of the article is matching decompilation: developers rebuild source code so that, with the original compiler and settings, it produces a byte-for-byte match for the original programme. That pass-or-fail check gives an AI coding agent a way to test its own work, retry and move on without asking a person to inspect every attempt.

Read TechSpot’s analysis. It describes projects spanning classic games, newer console software and business systems. In one example, developers used 17 AI agents to rebuild a playable version of 2009’s Call of Duty: Modern Warfare 2. The project’s developer later said it consumed 600 to 700 billion tokens over three months. TechSpot says progress improved when automated checks compared reconstructed code against the original executable.

The same principle can apply to some legacy software jobs: when a system produces predictable outputs, an agent can rewrite the logic and compare results. But the article draws a boundary around real-time mainframe systems, where the agent cannot run the full check-and-revise loop in the same way.

Why it matters

This is a more useful explanation than the familiar claim that AI can simply “write software”. In these examples, the big change is that a machine can keep trying when success has a clear definition. Where no dependable check exists, the agent may produce convincing-looking code that changes how a programme works.

That distinction matters well beyond games. Rebuilding a library or business process is not the same as reproducing a file format or making a game launch. A narrow test can verify a narrow result; it cannot certify every feature, behaviour or legal question around a reconstruction.

Our read

The answer key is the real story. AI makes iteration cheaper and more relentless, but a trustworthy check is what separates useful reconstruction from plausible-looking guesswork. For anyone considering AI-assisted migration, the practical lesson is to define what must remain true and test it against the old system, not merely admire the new code.

What to watch

  • Whether reconstruction projects publish tests that cover behaviour, not just successful builds or matching outputs.
  • How teams handle systems where reliable automated comparisons are difficult or impossible.
  • Whether AI-assisted software migrations show measurable results on live business workloads.

Discussion spark: For AI-assisted software reconstruction, should a strict test suite be enough to trust the result, or must people still review the code and its behaviour?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.