Discussion

AI agents could strip law firms of their training ground, argues legal executive

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#10576

AI agents could take over the repetitive work that teaches junior lawyers to spot mistakes, argues Rob Aberdein, a legal executive at Hoxton Wealth and Simpson & Marwick Group. His warning is not that firms should stop adopting AI, but that they must deliberately replace the learning those tasks once provided.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

In a Scotsman commentary published on 2 November, Aberdein says tasks such as reviewing leases and drafting routine letters helped trainees build professional judgement. If agents do that work in minutes, he argues, firms could become more efficient while weakening the pipeline of lawyers expected to supervise those same systems.

His proposed response is practical: bring junior lawyers closer to client calls and negotiations, ask them to critique AI-generated drafts, and make feedback and tracking their experience part of supervision. Aberdein acknowledges he has not fully solved the training question, but argues that simply slowing adoption or inventing busywork is not the answer.

Why it matters

The debate is not only about which legal tasks software can perform. If a lawyer remains accountable for an agent’s work, they need enough experience to recognise when a polished draft is quietly wrong. Removing routine work without replacing its teaching value could leave firms with a skills gap that efficiency gains do not show on the invoice.

Our read

Aberdein’s most useful point is that training cannot be left to happen by osmosis once the work that used to teach it is automated. His suggestions give firms a starting point: involve trainees earlier, make reviewing agent output an exercise in judgement, and give supervisors responsibility for what each junior has actually learned.

That is a more interesting question than whether AI can draft a letter. The Scotsman commentary makes the case for redesigning legal training, not preserving repetitive work for its own sake.

What to watch

  • Whether law firms build structured training around reviewing and challenging AI-generated work.
  • Whether junior lawyers get more direct exposure to clients, advice and negotiations.
  • Whether firms can show that faster work is producing lawyers equipped to supervise it.

Discussion spark: If AI takes over the routine work that once trained junior lawyers, should firms be expected to replace that learning with structured supervision, even if it costs more?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.