Discussion

AI agents could unsettle advertising and software subscriptions, analysts warn

In The AI Economy

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#14059

AI agents that shop and manage tasks for people could weaken the attention and hassle that keep parts of the internet economy profitable. UBS and Bank of America analysts have set out the risk, while Bending Spoons says it has not seen agents driving cancellations or switches at its businesses.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Ulrike Hoffmann-Burchardi, UBS Wealth Management’s chief investment officer for the Americas, argues that websites built for people clicking through pages may struggle when agents compare products and buy on someone’s behalf. She says brands will need machine-readable product information and live inventory, not just search-engine optimisation. Agents could also reduce demand for some software subscriptions if employees can use them to work across services without the usual dashboards or extra seats.

Bank of America applies that concern to Bending Spoons, which owns subscription businesses including AOL, Eventbrite and Evernote. Its analysts rate about 29% of the company’s projected 2027 revenue as at high risk from AI agents. That is an analyst assessment, not a measure of cancellations already caused by AI: BofA says it has not yet tracked data to test its hypotheses. Bending Spoons told Fortune it has seen no signs of agent-driven cancellations or customers switching to alternatives.

Why it matters

The proposed pressure point is unusually ordinary: an agent can do the tedious comparison or cancellation that people often put off. BofA says experts it consulted estimated that 10% to 40% of subscription payers may not use the products they pay for. If agents make it easier to find and cancel forgotten subscriptions, convenience may stop being quite the moat it was.

But the article also supplies the important brake on the forecast. BofA has not established that agents are already causing cancellations at scale, and Bending Spoons says its own business indicators show no such signs. A plausible threat is not yet a proven revenue trend.

Our read

This is more than a prediction that agents will replace a few clicks. It asks whether businesses can keep charging for convenience when software can take on the inconvenient bits. The evidence is early and the scale of the risk is uncertain, so treat the revenue estimate as a hypothesis to test, not a bill already due. The first useful evidence will be what happens to customer behaviour, not another round of dramatic agent demos.

What to watch

  • Bending Spoons’ third-quarter results, due on 20 November, for signs of changes in customer retention or growth.
  • Whether companies make product data and inventory usable by agents, as UBS argues they will need to.
  • Whether analysts publish data showing agents are actually driving subscription cancellations or software-seat reductions.

Discussion spark: If an AI agent can find and cancel subscriptions people no longer use, is that healthy competition or a business model companies should be allowed to defend?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.