Discussion

AI can produce the words. What happens to the work of learning to write?

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#11893

AI-written novels are appearing on digital bookshelves, and universities are facing questions about what writing courses are for when software can produce text in seconds. In an Oman Observer opinion piece, Sandhya Rao Mehta argues that writing is not just a finished page: it is also the process of testing ideas, making judgements and finding an individual voice.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Mehta says faculty members are increasingly frustrated by students using AI to write reports, essays and even research papers. She describes familiar responses, including in-class writing and oral assessment, while noting that these can be difficult to manage in large classes.

The piece also points to research suggesting that readers judge creative writing less favourably when told it was produced partly or wholly by AI. It cites University of Michigan research on that response, and a Sultan Qaboos University study concerning students’ need to express their own opinions in a voice that feels immediate and personal. The article provides no study methods or figures, so those findings are best treated as the author presents them, not as a verdict on every learner or reader.

Why it matters

The argument is more interesting than “AI writes, therefore writing is over”. If writing is part of how people learn to interpret, question and shape ideas, then replacing the final essay may also change what students practise along the way.

That leaves educators with a practical problem: how to make room for useful AI assistance without losing sight of the thinking a writing assignment is meant to develop. In-class work and oral assessment are possible responses, but Mehta notes the strain of giving individual attention to large classes.

Our read

Mehta makes a persuasive case for separating the convenience of producing text from the value of learning to write. Her piece is an opinion argument, not evidence that AI-written work is always hollow or that traditional assignments are beyond repair. Still, it asks a worthwhile question: if the process is part of the lesson, schools need to assess more than the polished page.

What to watch

  • Whether educators make the intended learning goals of writing assignments clearer.
  • How schools balance AI use with practice in forming and expressing original judgements.
  • Whether further research tests how AI authorship affects readers and students. Activity teaser: AI can make a page appear in seconds, but writing courses are meant to teach more than page production. An Oman Observer opinion piece argues that the work of forming ideas and finding a voice matters too. That distinction puts a practical challenge to educators: how can students use AI without outsourcing the thinking an assignment is meant to teach? Read the full story, then weigh in.

Discussion spark: When AI can produce a polished essay, should schools assess the final work, the thinking process behind it, or both?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.