Discussion

AI-drafted court claims are adding work for judges, Lady Chief Justice says

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#11966

People representing themselves in court are increasingly using AI to prepare their cases, according to the Lady Chief Justice’s annual report. The report describes a practical strain on courts: judges and staff can spend time working out what remedy a litigant is actually seeking.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The report, which reviews the year to September 2026, says more litigants in person used AI to construct claims in parts of the High Court’s Administrative Court and civil work in the King’s Bench Division. It also notes AI use in grounds of appeal prepared by unrepresented people in criminal cases.

The Law Society Gazette reported on the findings; Resultsense summarises the report and its account. The Lady Chief Justice recognises that AI transcription and summarising could help reduce backlogs, while saying oversight and decision-making must remain judge-led.

Why it matters

The account is not that AI-written claims are necessarily weak. The pressure point identified is that some claims take longer to understand, including working out what a person is asking the court to do. That matters to court capacity, and to people trying to navigate proceedings without legal representation.

It also makes this more than a question of whether AI should be allowed in court. The tools may help people prepare a case, but clearer guidance on stating the remedy sought could address the specific friction the report describes.

Our read

There is a useful distinction here: helping someone put their case into words is not the same as helping them identify the right legal remedy. AI may widen access, but access is not much use if the request reaches a judge in a fog. Guidance that helps litigants say plainly what they want the court to do looks like a more practical response than treating AI use itself as the problem.

What to watch

  • Whether the criminal appeal court publishes the guidance being drafted on AI-assisted grounds.
  • Whether courts offer litigants clearer help on stating the remedy they seek.
  • Whether future reporting separates added workload from the quality or outcome of AI-assisted claims.

Discussion spark: Should courts provide specific guidance for people using AI to prepare claims, or risk that making AI easier to use will add still more work for judges?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.