Some company boards are using AI to analyse papers, rehearse difficult discussions and challenge directors’ arguments. The shift offers a useful sounding board, but giving a bot a formal vote would raise a rather larger question: who is accountable when it gets things wrong?
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The use described ranges from summarising board papers and tidying minutes to helping directors plan agendas, examine years of data and argue against proposed deals. Board software company Diligent’s chief executive, Brain Strafford, says some executives are experimenting with digital replicas of colleagues to rehearse difficult conversations. One chief executive told him they would replace a couple of directors with AI, half-jokingly asking whether it could be priced at half the cost.
Fortune reports that Lloyds Banking Group has acknowledged using an AI agent to support boardroom activities, including agenda planning and analysis. Other examples include boards using AI to break discussion stalemates, and executives asking it to play the role of an activist investor. These are reported uses, not evidence that AI should take directors’ seats.
Why it matters
Board papers can contain unpublished results, proposed deals and succession plans. The article notes that some directors may use consumer chatbots when they lack access to company-approved tools, raising practical questions about where sensitive information goes. It also cites a survey in which half of US public companies lack a board-specific AI policy, while only 14 per cent have provided directors with approved AI tools.
There is a distinction between using AI to prepare or challenge a decision and handing it the decision itself. Directors remain responsible for their duties; a bot cannot take on a director’s legal responsibilities. A useful challenger may sharpen debate. A vote-bearing bot would move from helpful guest to a participant nobody can hold personally to account.
Our read
AI looks most useful here as a tireless devil’s advocate: ask it to argue against a deal, test assumptions or surface gaps in a dense pack of papers. That is a more compelling role than pretending a model can replace judgement, trust or legal responsibility. Boards should settle what data their tools can access and what decisions remain human before the bot gets a seat, let alone a vote.
What to watch
- Whether boards publish clear rules for using AI with sensitive papers and meeting records.
- Whether AI stays an advisory tool or is given a formal role in decisions.
- How boards test AI-generated challenges for errors, bias and misplaced confidence.
Discussion spark: Should boards use AI as a formal dissenting voice in decisions, or does that risk giving a tool influence without accountability?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (10 November 2026, 12:04 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.