Discussion

AI is reshaping college applications, and admissions offices are scrambling to catch up

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13539

AI is changing how students prepare college applications and how some universities assess them, CNN reports. The clearest sign of the scramble: UNC-Chapel Hill reversed an attempt to automatically score essays for writing quality after widespread use of AI-assisted writing made those ratings less useful.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

With the 1 January Common App deadline approaching, students are using chatbots to brainstorm, edit essays and research universities. Colleges are responding unevenly: Caltech says students may use AI to generate questions or kick-start ideas, but calls replacing their own voice unethical. It also uses AI to read students’ scientific research and generate questions for faculty to review.

Some universities are testing AI to handle large application volumes, while others are changing the application itself. Tulane has dropped its “Why Tulane?” essay; the university told CNN that concerns about AI played a part. The report also describes families using Claude to compare university costs, financial aid and campus preferences.

Why it matters

This is not just a question of whether an essay was written by a chatbot. Students are using AI for guidance and research, while universities are experimenting with AI to evaluate applications. That creates a messy fairness question: applicants may see AI assistance as a useful resource, but automated scoring can lose value when applicants use the same tools to shape their writing.

There is no single shared rulebook. Caltech draws a line between brainstorming and replacing a student’s voice; other institutions have different policies, and some are changing what they ask applicants to write. A polished essay may become a less reliable signal of how a student thinks, but removing essays raises its own questions about what should take their place.

Our read

The practical takeaway for applicants is to check each university’s policy rather than assume that one school’s rules apply everywhere. Using AI to compare costs or explore options is different from submitting work that replaces your own voice, and universities are drawing that distinction in different ways.

The more important test for admissions offices is whether their assessment methods still measure what they intend to measure. When an AI writing tool can make automated writing scores less useful, the algorithm has not so much solved the admissions problem as joined it.

What to watch

  • Whether more universities publish specific rules on acceptable AI assistance.
  • Whether schools drop essays, redesign them or move towards interviews and supervised assessments.
  • Whether AI-assisted admissions tools are used to support human readers or to make decisions on their behalf.

Discussion spark: Should universities allow AI for brainstorming and research but prohibit AI-written application essays, or is that boundary too difficult to enforce fairly?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.