Discussion

AI is squeezing consulting’s billable-hour model, while putting graduate jobs under pressure

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#12855

AI is making some consulting advice easier for clients to obtain themselves, while automating tasks that once trained junior staff. Leaders at KPMG, EY and rival firm Elixirr describe an industry facing pressure on both how it earns money and how it brings people into the profession.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Svilena Tzekova, KPMG’s global head of consulting, told CNBC that a slice of advisory income had “literally” disappeared as clients found they could get some advice quickly themselves. Clients may talk about paying for results, she said, but procurement teams still compare bids by headcount and hourly rates. She called a commercially workable outcome-based model “very difficult” to reach. AI also brings costs of its own, including computing power and model-provider charges based on the volume of text processed.

The same technology is changing the work. Research, analysis and slide-making, traditionally entry-level consulting tasks, can now be largely automated. EY’s Paul Goodhew said AI can prepare the first round of matching figures to their evidence, work juniors once did manually. EY is adding roles in data preparation and product management, while Tzekova says her firm should give graduates responsibility earlier rather than stop hiring them.

Elixirr investor-relations chief Emiko Caerlewy-Smith told CNBC that preparing the firm’s data for AI use took six months. She argued that a challenger built without time-and-materials billing has an advantage over much larger rivals. Claire Trachet, founder of Trachet, warned that juniors who miss the groundwork may also miss the chance to develop professional judgement.

Why it matters

This is more than a dispute over consulting’s invoices. If AI takes over routine research and analysis, firms have to work out how to charge for advice clients can partly obtain themselves, and how to train the people expected to exercise judgement later. The billing model is still catching up: clients may ask to pay for outcomes, but procurement teams continue to compare day rates and headcount.

Our read

The sharpest tension is that the industry may need fewer hours of junior work without needing fewer capable future consultants. Moving graduates towards responsibility sooner could help, but it does not answer how they acquire judgement if the basic work disappears. And replacing hourly fees with outcome pricing is harder when buyers still shop by the hour. Efficiency has arrived; the career ladder and invoice have not yet agreed what to do about it.

What to watch

  • Whether large firms change graduate hiring in the next recruitment round.
  • Whether a major consultancy publishes a concrete outcome-based pricing offer for AI-led work.
  • How firms explain the route from automated junior tasks to experienced professional judgement.

Discussion spark: If AI removes the routine tasks that train junior consultants, should firms redesign graduate roles around earlier responsibility, or protect more of the old apprenticeship work?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.