Judicial review applications in England and Wales reached 2,630 in the first half of 2026, and academics say the available data does not yet show that AI-assisted claims are driving the increase. The dispute matters because public bodies could change how people access legal challenges based on an explanation the numbers have not established.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
In a blog published on 30 October, University of York academic Sam Guy and King’s College London academic Joe Tomlinson examine the rise in applications. At that rate, the total could reach 5,260 for the year, which they say would be 36% above 2025 and 56% above 2024. The sharpest growth is in the “civil (other)” category, which includes housing, planning and social security cases.
The authors discuss comments recorded in June meeting minutes from Mr Justice Chamberlain, who suspected that litigants in person using AI may be contributing. But their analysis finds neither of the indicators they examined showing the expected signs of a surge in weak AI-assisted claims: permission grant rates are not meaningfully outside earlier patterns, and “Totally Without Merit” certifications remain consistent with the past decade. The data does not identify which applications used AI.
Why it matters
A rising caseload and a plausible explanation are not the same thing. The available figures do not prove that AI is responsible, but they also cannot rule out AI-assisted claims that are well-founded or otherwise do not show up in the measures studied.
That distinction matters if courts or public bodies are considering procedural changes. Without records of AI use, a change in case volumes can easily be mistaken for evidence about why those cases were filed.
Our read
The academics’ conclusion is a useful brake on a tidy story: AI is a possible factor, not an established cause. Public bodies should measure its use directly before treating case numbers as a verdict on it. The paperwork, for once, should include the evidence behind the paperwork.
What to watch
- Whether later research records AI use in applications directly.
- Whether permission grant rates or “Totally Without Merit” certifications change over time.
- Whether courts or public bodies propose procedural changes based on an assumed AI effect.
Discussion spark: Should courts ask people to declare when they used AI to prepare a claim, or would that add a new barrier to bringing a case?
Sources and evidence
- Judicial review claims rise, but AI's role remains unclear – Resultsense (2 November 2026, 09:27 UTC)
- PlanAssist AI planning tool moves to 15 English councils – Resultsense (2 November 2026, 09:27 UTC)
- Big AI firms back a shared opt-out signal for AI training – Resultsense (2 November 2026, 09:27 UTC)
- Data centre covenant is a 'golden ticket', Foxglove warns – Resultsense (2 November 2026, 09:27 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.