AI could create new jobs as well as displace existing ones, argues Xu Haoqing, an associate research fellow at the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences’ Artificial Intelligence Economics Research Office. His central point is that workers need help making that transition, not just assurances that new roles will appear.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
In an opinion article for CGTN, Xu describes the “reinstatement effect”: technology can replace tasks while creating new ones, and productivity gains can also support employment by lowering costs and increasing demand. He argues that automation has historically created routes back into work, but says this process is not automatic.
Xu points to short-term unemployment and skills mismatches as risks during the change. He also says research finds occupations highly exposed to AI can see lower labour demand, while new technologies may widen wage gaps within occupations and suppress wage growth. The article argues that, without effective public policy, the gains may accrue mainly to capital owners and technology controllers.
Why it matters
The distinction is more useful than the familiar choice between “AI takes all the jobs” and “technology always creates more”. Even if new work emerges overall, it may not appear where displaced workers live, arrive when they need it, or pay enough to make the transition manageable.
Xu’s proposals include targeted vocational training and re-employment programmes, stronger skill certification and employment services, and support for emerging industries and technologies that complement workers. Those are policy recommendations, not a guarantee that new roles will match the jobs AI changes.
Our read
The article makes a case for treating job transitions as a practical policy problem, rather than assuming the labour market will tidy everything up on its own. The historical argument is a useful corrective to simple forecasts, but it does not settle how many jobs AI will create, for whom, or on what terms.
What to watch
- Whether AI-exposed occupations see sustained changes in hiring and wages.
- Whether retraining programmes lead to jobs workers can actually access.
- Whether productivity gains are shared broadly or concentrated among firms and investors.
Discussion spark: If AI creates new jobs while displacing existing ones, should employers bear more responsibility for retraining affected workers, or should that burden sit mainly with governments?
Sources and evidence
- Reshaping employment in the AI Era: Reinstatement or displacement? – CGTN (2 November 2026, 09:02 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.