Discussion

AI may speed up bureaucracy. Who gets to decide what it does?

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13440

AI could make government administration faster, but efficiency is not the same as democratic legitimacy. In an opinion article for ERR, Tallinn University comparative-politics professor Mari-Liis Jakobson argues that people must retain control over political decisions and the ability to check what AI systems are doing.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Jakobson’s argument begins with bureaucracy: AI can process large volumes of information and handle repetitive procedures, making it tempting to use it for applications, policy analysis or even government services. But she warns that systems can become so complex that people struggle to understand how they work or influence their decisions.

She distinguishes administrative support from political authority. AI can help organise, translate and analyse information, she writes, while decisions about values, power and the kind of society people want should remain with people.

The article also raises concerns about AI-generated political media. Jakobson points to an AI-generated video posted on Hungarian prime minister Viktor Orbán’s official Facebook account that included a disclaimer, a fabricated audio recording circulated before Slovakia’s 2023 election, and AI-generated images used by Germany’s Alternative for Germany party. She argues that political parties should discuss transparent principles for campaign use and that voters and journalists should be prepared for convincing fabricated material close to an election.

Why it matters

The debate is not simply whether AI can process paperwork faster. It is where administrative help ends and authority begins, and whether the people affected can understand and challenge decisions. Election media adds another pressure point: a convincing fake released just before voting may leave little time for a correction to catch up.

Jakobson’s examples and proposals are arguments in an opinion piece, not evidence that AI has taken over government or that a political agreement will follow. They do, however, make the stakes concrete: governments and parties could set boundaries before a crisis forces the question.

Our read

Use AI to help make public services less laborious, by all means. But speed is a poor substitute for accountability, and “the system decided” is not a democratic answer. Clear rules for political use and meaningful ways to question automated decisions should be part of the conversation before deployment becomes routine.

What to watch

  • Whether political parties agree on transparent rules for AI-generated campaign material.
  • How governments define which public decisions AI may support, and which must remain accountable to people.
  • Whether election authorities and newsrooms prepare for convincing fabricated material released shortly before voting.

Discussion spark: Should governments be allowed to let AI make consequential administrative decisions if people can appeal them, or must a person make the initial decision too?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.