AI scribes can let doctors spend less time typing and more time looking at patients, but they can also get clinically important details wrong. Family physician Mara Gordon describes how one such tool turns a recorded appointment into a draft medical note, and why she checks it before signing.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
In an NPR advice column published on 17 November, Gordon explains that her phone app records a consultation, transcribes it and uses a medical language model to produce a note. In her practice, she asks patients for permission first; if they decline, she takes notes herself as she did before using the tool.
Gordon says the recordings are uploaded to a cloud service rather than kept on her phone, and that scribe systems generally delete recordings and notes after a set period. The column does not give a retention period for her specific service. Gordon also recounts errors she has encountered, including mistakes about a patient’s age or gender and confusion between “I do” and “I do not”.
Why it matters
A generated note is not just a convenient summary. It can become part of a medical record, where an error may be repeated or relied on later. Gordon says she reads and edits the draft before signing it. Clinical informatics specialist Eileen Kim warns in the column that when busy clinicians lack time to review AI-generated notes, mistakes could carry through the record.
The technology can also change the conversation itself. Gordon says it helps her look at patients rather than her computer, while acknowledging that some may feel uneasy about a recording or worry about where their information goes. The same tool can make a visit feel more attentive to one patient and less private to another.
Our read
The useful distinction is between an AI scribe drafting a note and a clinician taking responsibility for the final record. Gordon’s account gives patients a practical question to ask: what is recorded, where it goes, how long it is kept, and whether they can decline? In her practice, declining means the appointment continues with the old-fashioned keyboard. Not glamorous, but reassuringly functional.
What to watch
- Whether a clinic can explain its recording, storage and deletion practices in plain language.
- Whether clinicians have time to review and correct AI-generated notes before signing them.
- Whether patients who decline recording can still receive care without penalty.
Discussion spark: Should clinics have to explain exactly how an AI scribe stores and deletes recordings before asking patients to agree, even if that makes already-busy appointments longer?
Sources and evidence
- I’m a human doctor with human intelligence. But I sure do like my AI notetaker – NPR (17 November 2026, 11:00 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.