AI-assisted complaints and court claims are drawing concern across UK redress systems. But the available court figures do not show whether AI is behind the rise in claims, or whether it is changing their quality.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
A Resultsense analysis published on 13 November examines research by Sam Guy and Joe Tomlinson into rising judicial review applications. The researchers found that applications are increasing, but the share granted permission and the share certified as “Totally Without Merit” remain broadly in line with earlier years. Those measures cannot establish whether people used AI to draft claims, let alone whether AI caused the increase.
The analysis also brings together signs of AI use elsewhere in redress. A 2025 briefing by the Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman lists generative AI among several possible drivers of rising complaints, alongside pressure on public services and improved accessibility. It does not quantify AI’s share. A survey cited in the analysis found that 16.3% of 1,428 people reporting a legal dispute in the previous two years had turned to an AI chatbot for help.
Why it matters
Longer or inaccurate submissions can add work for councils, ombudsmen and courts. The analysis cites the Financial Ombudsman Service chief describing a submission with 37 incorrect references out of 39, and says the service is phoning more consumers to identify the real issue. Those examples show the sort of administrative burden being discussed, not how common it is.
There is a harder question beneath the paperwork: restricting access because institutions suspect AI is flooding the system could also deter people with valid complaints. The same analysis notes that complaints can expose real failures, and that court figures have not yet shown a clear rise in weak claims.
Our read
The useful conclusion is not that AI has swamped UK justice, nor that it has had no effect. The evidence described here cannot yet separate AI’s role from other reasons caseloads are growing. That uncertainty matters: institutions need to plan for the work arriving now without mistaking suspicion for a count.
What to watch
- The next judicial review statistics, especially whether permission rates or “Totally Without Merit” certifications change as volumes rise.
- The Ombudsman’s planned research into the drivers of complaint demand.
- Whether courts and first-tier complaint services collect evidence on AI use while improving how they identify the issue a person is trying to raise.
Discussion spark: Should redress bodies ask people to disclose AI use in complaints and court claims, or would that create a barrier before anyone has shown that AI is making those claims weaker?
Sources and evidence
- AI-assisted claims are testing UK redress, but the court data shows no clear signal yet – Resultsense (13 November 2026, 11:01 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.