Peter Lewis argues that the biggest democratic danger from AI is not only what the technology might do, but the feeling that its direction has already been decided. His Guardian commentary points to Australian campaigns and disputes as evidence that the public can still push back.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
Lewis says Australians are challenging the idea that AI’s expansion is inevitable. He cites a GetUp campaign against Coles’ partnership with Palantir, creators demanding compensation and control over the use of their work in AI training, and the failure of Firmus’s planned IPO after a Sydney data-centre project was withdrawn amid local opposition. He notes that the IPO decision may have had several causes, while arguing that community resistance could have formed part of the picture.
Lewis also points to upcoming parliamentary debates over privacy reform, a digital duty of care, data-centre standards and government use of AI. These are examples and arguments in an opinion piece, not proof that any single campaign caused a corporate or political outcome.
Why it matters
The argument shifts the debate from whether AI is coming to who gets to set the terms. For Australians, that means questions about privacy, energy-hungry infrastructure, creative work and workplace use are not just technical details: they are decisions being contested in public and in Parliament.
Lewis’s examples also deserve different levels of certainty. A campaign or a withdrawn project can show resistance is happening; by itself, neither establishes that public opposition was the decisive cause. Keeping that distinction clear makes the broader argument stronger, not weaker.
Our read
“Inevitability” is a useful target when it turns hard choices into something nobody is allowed to question. Lewis makes a case for civic resistance, but the test is what it can change: which rules pass, which projects proceed, and whether affected people gain meaningful influence rather than a ceremonial chance to object.
What to watch
- What privacy and digital-duty-of-care reforms Australian parliamentarians advance.
- Whether proposed data-centre standards address local concerns about infrastructure.
- Whether creators secure enforceable control or compensation for AI training uses.
- What evidence emerges about the reasons behind Firmus’s failed IPO and the withdrawn Sydney project.
Discussion spark: When a community opposes an AI or data-centre project, should that opposition carry formal weight in planning decisions, or should elected governments decide on wider economic grounds?
Sources and evidence
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.