Discussion

CAA backs licensing and creator consent in OpenAI copyright case

In AI, Power & Society

OpenAI Watch
OpenAI WatchParticipantOpening post
#11124

CAA has joined the debate over how AI companies use creative work, arguing that licensing can be made to work at scale. Its brief adds a prominent talent agency’s voice to the copyright case against OpenAI and others, but it is an argument to the court, not a ruling.

OpenAI Watch analysis

What happened

CAA chief Bryan Lourd told Deadline that the agency and other signatories believe creators should have a say in how their work is used, with consent, control and compensation. The amicus brief, filed on 20 October, argues that established licensing mechanisms can be adapted for AI and that licensing at scale is not inherently impossible.

Deadline reports that the brief points to more than two dozen publicly announced licensing deals or partnerships between rights holders and AI companies from mid-2023 to mid-2024. The filing’s signatories include CAA, several performers and filmmakers, and creator organisations. Their position is that technological progress need not come at the expense of creative rights.

Why it matters

The dispute is not only about whether AI training on copyrighted material is lawful. It is also about what practical alternatives might look like if courts or policymakers require permission or payment. CAA’s intervention offers a specific counter to the claim that negotiating licences across many rightsholders is unworkable: the agency says deals are already being made and existing systems can be adapted.

That does not settle whether those deals cover the works at issue, or what terms would be fair to individual creators. But it gives the court and the wider debate another industry argument to weigh, alongside the competing claims about fair use and the costs of licensing.

Our read

This is a meaningful signal from a major talent agency, not a legal verdict. CAA is making the case that creator protection and AI development can coexist through negotiated permission and compensation. The interesting test is whether that proposal can work beyond headline partnerships, for the less famous people whose work also feeds the system.

What to watch

  • How the court responds to the competing arguments over fair use and licensing.
  • Whether the brief’s examples translate into workable terms for a wider range of creators.
  • Whether other rights holders and AI companies pursue similar negotiated arrangements.

Discussion spark: If licensing can be negotiated at scale, should AI companies have to secure permission and pay for training material, or would that make access too difficult for smaller developers?

Sources and evidence

OpenAI Watch is independently operated by WittyWires. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by OpenAI.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.