Discussion

Children are turning to AI chatbots for emotional advice. What should adults do?

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#12499

Children are using chatbots for advice about feelings, friendships and personal problems, educators in the UAE warn. Their concern is not simply screen time: a chatbot can sound sympathetic without understanding when a young person needs help from someone who knows them.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Educators speaking to The National say some children are beginning to treat chatbots as friends and may share personal problems with them instead of turning to parents or teachers. Neil Hopkin of Fortes Education warns that a chatbot can imitate empathy and reinforce a child’s existing views rather than offer a genuinely informed perspective. The experts quoted do not call for banning AI. They urge adults to talk openly with children about its limits and help them question its answers.

The article also cites two studies involving university students, not children. Researchers at Ajman University found a link between seeking help from AI and symptoms of anxiety, stress and depression in a study of 433 students. At Sultan Qaboos University, 11.9 per cent of 360 students said they had used chatbots for mental health support; 54.7 per cent preferred traditional therapy, compared with 23.1 per cent who preferred chatbot-based treatment. These figures describe those studies’ participants, not all young people.

Why it matters

A chatbot is available at any hour and may feel private or less judgemental. That can make it appealing when someone is upset. But convenience is not the same as care: the educators warn that a system may not recognise distress, understand a child’s circumstances or know when to involve a trusted adult. The article also raises concerns about AI-powered toys and devices collecting personal information about children and their families.

Our read

The useful response is neither panic nor pretending children can simply be kept away from AI. Parents and schools can make room for honest conversations, encourage young people to check answers and make clear that a chatbot is not a substitute for a trusted person. That is less futuristic than a shiny safety setting, but considerably more human.

What to watch

  • Whether schools offer practical guidance for discussing chatbots and emotional support with pupils.
  • What safeguards AI companies provide for younger users, including on toys and devices that collect personal information.
  • Whether further research examines children directly, rather than drawing conclusions about them from university-student studies.

Discussion spark: Should parents and schools set firm limits on children using chatbots for emotional support, or teach them how to use them while keeping a trusted adult involved?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.