Discussion

CIBSE says AI must support engineers’ judgement, not replace it

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#12874

CIBSE has published a position statement on AI in building engineering, arguing that AI-generated work must be checked by qualified professionals. Its central point is practical as well as principled: engineers remain professionally and legally accountable for their work, whether or not they use AI.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Chartered Institution of Building Services Engineers says its AI Working Group developed the statement in response to rising adoption of AI tools across professional practice. CIBSE identifies potential uses including supporting engineering expertise, helping with complex tasks and reducing repetitive work. It says those gains could free engineers to focus on higher-value work and contribute to better-performing, more sustainable buildings.

But in a field where building safety matters, CIBSE says AI use should be backed by professional judgement, human verification and a clear understanding of legal and professional responsibilities. It also calls for continued learning, critical thinking and maintaining core engineering skills. The Scottish Construction Now report quotes CIBSE’s head of knowledge and digital, Ahmed Hegazi, saying technology must support professional judgement, never replace it.

Why it matters

This is a useful boundary for an industry where AI-generated recommendations could feed into work with real safety consequences. CIBSE is not arguing that engineers should avoid the tools; it is saying that using them does not transfer responsibility to the software. That distinction matters when a confident-looking output still needs professional scrutiny.

The statement sets out a professional position, not evidence that AI has already improved building safety or productivity. Its value will depend on whether the principles show up in everyday practice, training and accountability.

Our read

“Keep a qualified person responsible” is not the flashiest AI strategy, but it is a rather sensible place to start when buildings and people are involved. CIBSE’s position leaves room for useful tools while resisting the tempting fiction that automation makes professional judgement optional.

For engineers and firms adopting AI, the practical takeaway is to keep verification and accountability attached to the work, not buried in a product demo.

What to watch

  • How CIBSE turns the statement into practical guidance for members and firms.
  • Whether engineering organisations set clear processes for checking AI-generated work.
  • How the profession balances new AI tools with training and core engineering skills.

Discussion spark: When AI contributes to engineering work with safety consequences, should professional bodies set firm rules for human verification, or should that be left to individual firms and engineers?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.