One software engineer has used Claude Code to build seven free, open-source alternatives to Adobe Creative Cloud apps. Adobe executives say the challenge is not just recreating features: it is matching professional control and making the tools work together.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The project, ArtCraft, includes alternatives to Photoshop, Lightroom, Premiere Pro, Illustrator, Acrobat, After Effects and InDesign. MakeUseOf reports that software engineer Brandon Thomas built the suite with Claude Opus 5.5, drawing on 15 years of software engineering experience, and released it for people to download, use and contribute to.
At Adobe MAX, MakeUseOf asked three senior Adobe executives why users should keep paying for Creative Cloud. Zorana Gee argued that reliable, professional-grade software takes more than reproducing individual features. Meg Donovan pointed to the way Adobe apps work together, while Photoshop product director Stephen Nielsen highlighted precise control, including editable layers and masks for AI-assisted changes.
Why it matters
This is a tangible example of AI coding tools helping one developer build a much broader software alternative, not merely a small app or a coding demo. It gives people who need only a few creative tools another option to explore, while putting a sharper question to subscription software makers: what is worth paying for when functional alternatives are easier to attempt?
The comparison has limits. MakeUseOf’s writer says ArtCraft handled some everyday tasks but still lacked capabilities, particularly in AI-powered editing. The article does not establish that the suite can replace Adobe’s products for demanding professional workflows. A list of app names is not the same thing as a mature creative ecosystem, inconvenient as that may be for both sides of the debate.
Our read
ArtCraft is worth watching as a practical test of what AI-assisted development can put within reach. Adobe’s strongest answer is not simply that it has more features: it is that depth, dependable workflows and interoperability matter. Whether those advantages justify a subscription will depend on what people actually need from the software, not how impressive the demo looks.
For occasional editing or document work, a free alternative may be enough. Professionals whose work depends on complex files, collaboration and support have more to weigh before switching. The interesting story is not that AI has made Adobe obsolete; it is that the cost of challenging established software may be falling.
What to watch
- Whether ArtCraft’s seven apps gain users, contributors and sustained development.
- How well the alternatives handle complex projects and compatibility with existing files.
- Whether AI coding tools make it easier to build useful alternatives, or mainly to create promising first versions.
Discussion spark: For creative software, what deserves the subscription price most: professional reliability and tools that work together, or access to capable alternatives that are free and open source?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (16 November 2026, 20:31 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.