Cloudflare says Quad9’s planned withdrawal of its free public DNS resolver from France shows the consequences of court-ordered website blocking. The company says a Belgian order could put similar pressure on Cloudflare, Google and Cisco early next year, and that the companies have appealed.
Cloudflare Watch analysis
What happened
In a new post, Cloudflare says Quad9 decided to leave France after a court imposed daily financial penalties for not blocking domains associated with alleged copyright infringement. Cloudflare argues that a public DNS resolver cannot remove infringing material, only stop returning the address of a whole domain.
Cloudflare also says a Belgian court order would require it, Google and Cisco to begin blocking websites through their public resolvers by early January 2027, or face substantial penalties. It says the three companies have appealed. Cloudflare notes that a French court rejected penalties against it after finding that other measures it had taken through its CDN and reverse-proxy service were sufficient to comply with the underlying order.
Why it matters
Public DNS resolvers translate website names into the addresses devices need to connect. Cloudflare argues that blocking at this layer can affect lawful material on the same domain, be bypassed by switching resolvers and leave users without a clear explanation when a site fails to load. Those are the company’s arguments against the orders, not a neutral assessment of their effectiveness.
The practical concern is that legal pressure could change which public resolvers remain available in a country. Cloudflare says Quad9 cannot directly warn people and organisations using its service in France, including hospitals, universities and government bodies, before it withdraws it.
Our read
This is an infrastructure dispute with a user-facing consequence: a blocking order aimed at piracy can also change how people reach the wider web. Cloudflare has a clear stake in opposing the orders, so its case deserves attribution, not a free pass. The useful test is whether courts and policymakers can target infringement without turning a domain lookup into a blunt, hard-to-explain barrier.
What to watch
- Whether the Belgian appeal changes the expected early-January 2027 deadline or the order’s scope.
- When Quad9 will withdraw its French resolver, and how affected users are notified.
- Whether courts continue pursuing blocking through public DNS providers, or focus on hosting providers instead.
Discussion spark: Should courts be able to require public DNS resolvers to block domains over copyright claims, even when the block can affect lawful material and users may not know why a site has stopped loading?
Sources and evidence
- Quad9’s withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine (17 November 2026, 20:24 UTC)
Independent WittyWires tracker for public updates about Cloudflare. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Cloudflare; this is not an official account.