Discussion

Could AI make the working week shorter? One writer argues the gains should buy back time

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#14056

AI could make people more productive, but that does not have to mean asking them to produce more. In a new opinion piece, Amit Baumel argues that society should use some of the gains to reduce how much of life work occupies.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Baumel’s argument in Psychology Today is that the long-term trend towards shorter working hours could continue as AI raises productivity. He points to the move from six-day to five-day working weeks, paid leave and experiments with four-day weeks, while stressing that these changes took collective bargaining, legislation and political struggle. Productivity made them economically possible; it did not hand them out automatically.

He sketches three possible responses if an employee can do in two hours what once took eight: demand four times the output, cut jobs, or convert some of the gain into time. Baumel favours the last option, arguing that widespread loss of work and income could also weaken household spending and social stability. His piece includes an illustration based on the 2023 US Consumer Expenditure Survey, comparing a potential decline in household spending with the roughly 4% fall in per-person consumption during the Great Recession.

Why it matters

The familiar argument about AI and jobs often stops at whether new roles will replace old ones. Baumel shifts the question to who benefits if the same work takes less time. A productivity gain can become higher output, fewer jobs or more free time. Those are economic and political choices, not automatic features of the technology.

His case is an optimistic argument, not evidence that AI will deliver a shorter working week. The spending illustration is a scenario, not a forecast of what AI will do to incomes or consumption. And, as Baumel notes, the history he invokes involved people organising and fighting for change.

Our read

The useful point is that “AI makes us more productive” leaves out the part that matters to workers: what happens to the time and value saved. Baumel makes a case for shorter working lives, but the path from more capable tools to a four-day week runs through employers, workers and policy. The technology may create room for that choice. It will not make the choice for us, however politely prompted.

What to watch

  • Whether employers turn AI-driven productivity gains into higher output, fewer roles or reduced hours.
  • Whether four-day-week experiments spread beyond a growing number of organisations.
  • How future evidence measures changes in working time, wages and household spending.

Discussion spark: If AI lets people do the same work in less time, should employers be expected to reduce working hours, or should the productivity gains go elsewhere?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.