Discussion

Dawn Butler’s proposed AI bill would require consent to use someone’s likeness

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#12238

Dawn Butler says her proposed AI bill would require consent before someone’s likeness is generated, with civil remedies and offences for unauthorised use. The Labour MP is asking the Government to turn those proposals into enforceable protections, bringing a concrete legislative plan into the debate over AI-generated faces and voices.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

In an article for Left Foot Forward, Butler says her Artificial Intelligence (Consent and Misuse) Bill would establish a consent requirement for creating someone’s likeness with AI. She says it would also provide for civil action where that requirement is breached, create offences relating to the creation or distribution of unauthorised likenesses, and place duties on AI providers to address misuse by people issuing commands.

Butler argues that responsibility should not rest solely with the person whose identity has been exploited. She also calls for transparency, safeguards against discrimination, accountability when harm occurs, and ways for people to challenge manipulated content. These are proposals described by Butler, not protections shown here as already in force.

Why it matters

The bill’s central idea is straightforward: making a convincing image, video or voice clone should not automatically make it fair game. Its proposed approach would put obligations on both the person using the likeness and the providers whose technology enables its creation.

That is a more specific policy argument than simply asking platforms to label synthetic media after the fact. But the article does not set out the bill’s full text, its legislative progress or the details of how provider duties would work in practice.

Our read

“Consent” is a strong starting point, not a complete rulebook. The hard questions are how it would apply to parody, public-interest reporting, deceased people and material created across borders, and what providers would have to do when a user tries to get around the rules. Butler’s proposal deserves attention because it names both a principle and mechanisms for enforcing it. The next test is whether the Government engages with the detail rather than leaving the idea at the level of a good slogan.

What to watch

  • Whether the Government responds to Butler’s request to adopt the proposals.
  • The bill’s text, progress and any amendments.
  • How consent, provider duties and remedies would apply to disputed or cross-border cases.

Discussion spark: Should AI likeness rules make consent the default, or would that give people too much power to block parody, criticism and public-interest uses?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.