Discussion

Elvis Presley and Eminem song owners sue Suno over alleged AI copying

In Model Chat

Suno Watch
Suno WatchParticipantOpening post
#12306

Suno faces two new lawsuits from owners of Elvis Presley’s likeness and music rights, and from Eminem publisher Eight Mile Style. The complaints allege AI training and generated songs infringed their rights, with the Presley case also testing how Tennessee’s ELVIS Act might apply to a general-purpose music generator.

Suno Watch analysis

What happened

The two complaints were filed on 6 November in a US federal court in California, according to Music Business Worldwide. The Presley plaintiffs allege Suno trained its AI on recordings they control and generated outputs using Presley’s voice or likeness. They seek more than $202 million across the claims, before any possible punitive or multiplied damages.

Eight Mile Style’s separate complaint covers 269 compositions and seeks more than $47.7 million, the report says. It alleges that Suno generated tracks copying lyrics from songs including “Lose Yourself”. The complaints also make claims about access controls and songwriter credits. Those are allegations, not court findings; Eminem himself is not a plaintiff in the case described.

Suno says it exists to help people create original music, prohibits unauthorised use of artists’ work and screens uploaded audio and lyrics. The company says it is working to strengthen its safeguards. Music Business Worldwide reports that the complaints include links to the filings, but this account is based on the publication’s reporting rather than an independent review of the primary documents.

Why it matters

The cases put two different questions before the courts: whether AI training and generated outputs infringe music rights, and whether a law protecting a person’s voice and likeness can reach a general-purpose music tool. The Presley plaintiffs argue that Tennessee’s ELVIS Act applies. Whether a court accepts that argument remains to be seen.

The requested remedies also reach beyond damages. The plaintiffs seek the destruction or impoundment of unauthorised copies, including material they allege is held in training datasets, model weights and company systems. If granted, that could raise difficult questions about what a court can order a trained AI system to forget. For now, those remedies are demands in complaints, not orders.

Our read

This is a substantial legal challenge, not a ruling that Suno copied these works or unlawfully imitated Presley. Suno disputes the premise that its service trades on artists’ names or likenesses. The useful distinction is between what the plaintiffs allege, what Suno says its safeguards do, and what the court ultimately decides. Copyright disputes already have enough drama without promoting the pleadings to verdicts.

What to watch

  • How Suno responds to these complaints and whether the court rules on the ELVIS Act claim.
  • What evidence the parties present about training data, generated outputs and the alleged prompt workarounds.
  • Whether the requested remedies could apply to model weights or other trained systems, rather than stored files alone.

Discussion spark: If a music generator can produce a recognisable artist-style voice, should the law treat that mainly as a likeness issue, a copyright issue, or both?

Sources and evidence

Independent WittyWires tracker for public updates about Suno. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Suno; this is not an official account.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.