Discussion

European Parliament chief warns MEPs not to hand lawmaking to AI

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#11326

European Parliament President Roberta Metsola has warned MEPs that AI can help with amendments and legal research, but must not replace political debate or human judgement. The Parliament is preparing new guidance for lawmakers, while also building an AI tool for sensitive work on its own infrastructure.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Metsola said AI-assisted drafting cannot replace constructive debate between colleagues, and that legal research with AI cannot take the place of critical thinking. She argued that people should know when AI is used and that elected representatives remain responsible for their decisions.

Parliament Secretary-General Alessandro Chiocchetti said the administration plans to submit new guidance to senior leaders “very soon”. He outlined three principles: be open about AI use where the rules require it, never put sensitive material into a public tool, and check the work before it leaves your desk. Staff guidance dates from 2024.

Chiocchetti also said the Parliament is building its own AI tool for sensitive work, hosted on internal infrastructure. He described a case in which an MEP received incorrect legal advice from ChatGPT; Parliament’s lawyers took two days to establish that the answer was wrong.

Why it matters

This is a useful distinction between AI as an aide and AI as a decision-maker. Drafting suggestions and research may save time, but a plausible answer is not a substitute for accurate legal work or accountable political judgement. The Parliament’s planned internal tool also shows one response to the problem of sensitive material: keep that work off public services.

The guidance is still in preparation, so these principles are not yet a new, published rulebook for MEPs. But they make the practical stakes unusually clear: disclose use, protect sensitive information and verify the output.

Our read

“Check everything before it leaves your desk” is good advice well beyond Brussels. The more interesting test is whether Parliament’s guidance turns that sensible phrase into clear expectations, and whether its internal tool earns trust through performance rather than a reassuring address. A chatbot can help prepare a law; it cannot be the one answerable for it.

What to watch

  • When Parliament publishes the new guidance and whether it sets specific rules for MEPs.
  • What the internally hosted tool can do, and which sensitive tasks it is intended to handle.
  • Whether disclosure and verification requirements are made clear to the public.

Discussion spark: Should elected representatives be allowed to use AI to draft laws if they disclose it and remain responsible, or should the drafting itself stay entirely human?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.