Discussion

Freshfields’ AI spin-out idea puts the law firm’s business model in play

In The AI Economy

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#8611

Freshfields partners are exploring whether to separate the firm’s AI unit into a business that could attract outside investors or float, while clients are also bringing more work in-house with AI. The tension is the story: selling tools more widely could create a new revenue stream, but those same tools may help clients need fewer billable hours.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

A Resultsense analysis published on 19 October connects leaked Freshfields emails, reported by the Financial Times, with a separate HSBC survey of UK law firms reported by City AM. The emails describe global managing partner Alan Mason working on a possible separate company for Freshfields’ AI business. The idea is at an early stage, and the Financial Times reported that it may come to nothing.

The analysis says 60% of 100 UK law firms in HSBC’s survey saw clients moving more work in-house as a disruption. Freshfields’ AI unit, Freshfields Lab, builds tools used by the firm’s lawyers and clients. No sales to outside firms or in-house legal teams had been made, according to the account.

Read the Resultsense analysis.

Why it matters

A separate company could give Freshfields’ software its own investors and customers, rather than leaving its value folded into a law firm. But the business case depends on whether the tools work for buyers without Freshfields’ own data and matters behind them. The analysis also notes that established legal-tech comparators already have large customer bases; Freshfields has yet to demonstrate comparable outside demand.

There is a second awkward question. If clients use AI to handle more legal work themselves, a firm selling them tools could strengthen its software business while putting pressure on its traditional fees. The technology may help a firm serve clients differently, but it does not make the pricing problem disappear. If anything, it gives that problem a new product launch.

Our read

This is a serious strategic possibility, not a completed deal or a confirmed valuation. The valuable distinction is between building impressive tools inside a law firm and proving they can stand alone as a software business. Freshfields may have an asset worth separating; the customers, portability and commercial terms still need to do the talking.

What to watch

  • Whether Freshfields formalises the proposal or brings in outside investors.
  • Whether Freshfields Lab sells to customers beyond the firm and its existing clients.
  • Whether other law firms separate their AI tools from their legal practices.
  • How firms price work when clients arrive with AI-generated research or advice.

Discussion spark: If a law firm’s AI tools help clients bring more work in-house, should the firm sell those tools anyway, or protect the legal practice that built them?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.