Discussion

Harvard Extension leaves classroom AI rules to instructors, with policies from bans to bounded use

In Developer Tools

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#11080

Harvard Extension School leaves AI rules largely to individual instructors, producing a mix of outright bans and narrowly permitted uses. The useful detail for students is that the school requires them to acknowledge AI assistance where it is allowed, but course policies can differ from and supersede the general guidance.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Harvard Crimson reports that most Extension School courses are online and that instructors set course-specific rules. In one biochemistry course, AI is barred from graded assignments but permitted for making study guides or practice problems outside graded work. In a quantitative reasoning course, AI may be used to explain confusing terms and generate practice problems.

The rules also vary by programme. The Extension School Writing Program prohibits AI at every stage, from brainstorming and outlining to drafting, revising and editing. For exams, instructors described using closed-book, human-proctored finals or in-class quizzes where students cannot access AI tools.

Why it matters

Students may encounter very different boundaries from one course to another, even within the same school. The practical rule is to check the syllabus: permitted use, required acknowledgement and exam restrictions are not uniform.

The examples also show why “AI allowed” or “AI banned” can be too blunt a summary. Some instructors distinguish between assessed work and study support; others prohibit AI throughout because writing the work is itself part of the learning objective.

Our read

A course-specific approach gives instructors room to match rules to what students are meant to learn. It also puts the burden on clear, consistent guidance. “Check the syllabus” is sensible advice, but students should not need a policy treasure hunt to know whether asking a chatbot for practice questions is acceptable.

What to watch

  • Whether course syllabuses state permitted uses and acknowledgement rules clearly.
  • How instructors handle AI access during exams in online courses.
  • Whether the school’s guidance changes as faculty refine their policies.

Discussion spark: Should universities set one consistent AI rule for all courses, or should instructors decide according to what each subject is trying to teach?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.