Discussion

Herald reports fabricated references in Scotland’s curriculum evidence papers

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13716

Scotland’s curriculum reform evidence papers contain fabricated references and other errors, The Herald reported, raising questions about the material being used to guide teachers. Education Secretary Màiri McAllan says AI supported the review and quality assurance, but did not write the documents.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Herald reported on 15 November that Edinburgh University lecturer Brodie Runciman found non-existent sources, misattributed quotations and factual mistakes in Education Scotland’s draft “background and evidence” papers. One paper reportedly put the number of pupils taking Higher PE above 200,000, against a figure of about 11,000. Runciman also said some errors appear in a draft technical framework intended to help teachers plan lessons.

According to the report, the papers cover subjects from literacy and science to maths and health. Education Scotland says its staff wrote the content and that approved AI tools were used to support review, clarity and quality assurance. McAllan has rejected calls to pause the work, describing it as important and saying more than 3,800 teachers, practitioners and experts have signed up to review the drafts.

Why it matters

These are draft materials, not the finished curriculum, which is due in classrooms from August 2028. But evidence papers can shape what reviewers and teachers treat as reliable. Errors in citations and figures are not decorative blemishes: they make it harder to check the reasoning behind a policy, especially when the documents are meant to support a broad reform.

The AI connection is specific, not an excuse to pin every mistake on a chatbot. Education Scotland says AI had a supporting role, while the Herald’s account describes errors that Runciman says he found in the papers. The available account does not establish which errors, if any, were caused by AI.

Our read

The useful response is neither “AI wrote it” nor “AI only helped, so carry on”. The papers need a transparent correction and reference-checking process, with clear responsibility for what makes it into the final evidence base. Draft status gives the review room to fix problems; it does not make the problems immaterial.

What to watch

  • Whether Education Scotland corrects the cited sources, figures and quotations identified in the reporting.
  • Whether officials publish a clear account of how AI-assisted review was used and checked.
  • Whether the revised evidence papers are available for scrutiny before the curriculum changes reach classrooms.

Discussion spark: Should Scotland pause the curriculum review until its evidence papers have been checked and corrected, or is a transparent correction process during the draft stage enough?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.