Discussion

HiBob research says AI is prompting HR teams to revisit workplace decisions

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#12822

AI is already informing decisions about pay rises, promotions, performance ratings and redundancies, according to research from HR software company HiBob. The figures also suggest some HR teams are using AI to challenge managers’ judgements, a consequential role that deserves more scrutiny than another productivity boast.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Global Recruiter reports that 57% of HR professionals using AI to review people decisions have reconsidered an employee initially passed over for promotion. It says 43% reported a more favourable final decision on pay rises and 40% on promotions after an AI-informed review.

Nearly three-quarters said they had used AI information to challenge a manager’s proposed decision. Among those using AI in recruitment or performance reviews, 40% reported a more favourable outcome for a candidate’s progression or job offer, while 42% said the same of employee performance ratings.

Why it matters

This is not just AI sorting paperwork. The reported uses reach decisions that can affect someone’s pay, career or job. The figures also point to a less obvious possibility: AI may sometimes prompt HR teams to reconsider a manager’s assessment, rather than simply automate it.

But these are reported survey findings, not proof that AI makes decisions fairer. The article does not provide the survey’s sample size or methodology, and the results come from research released by a company that sells HR software. That context matters when reading the upbeat framing.

Our read

The useful question is not whether AI should be allowed anywhere near people decisions in the abstract. It is whether it adds relevant evidence, whether someone checks that evidence, and whether the person affected can challenge the outcome. A second look can help; a machine-shaped answer dressed up as objectivity can still miss the point.

What to watch

  • Whether HiBob publishes the survey’s sample, methodology and question wording.
  • How HR teams verify AI-generated information before it affects an employment decision.
  • Whether workers are told when AI informs a decision and given a meaningful way to challenge it.

Discussion spark: Should AI be used to challenge managers’ decisions about pay and promotion, or do the risks of opaque evidence outweigh the chance of a second look?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.