Discussion

Irish artists tell Oireachtas committee AI is using their work without consent

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#14069

Irish artists and writers have told an Oireachtas committee that their work is being used without consent to train AI models and generate promotional material. Their testimony turns the broad argument over AI and creative work into a practical question for Ireland: what recourse, compensation and protection should creators have?

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Irish Times reports that Praxis chair Robbie Kitt said members’ work had been used without consent in AI-generated promotional content. He also said the union knew of incidents involving local authorities and publicly funded organisations using AI-generated photos, posters and videos. Kitt called for a national policy requiring public bodies to employ creatives rather than use AI to replace their labour.

The committee also heard calls for routes to challenge unlawfully scraped work and for adequate compensation. Visual Artists Ireland chief executive Noel Kelly said individual artists may lack the legal resources to pursue claims. Irish Writers Union representative Conor Kostick warned that AI-generated books could further undermine writers’ already precarious livelihoods. These are concerns and proposals presented to the committee, not findings that any particular company has acted unlawfully.

The Irish Times report also covers a separate committee discussion about AI and employment. International Labour Organisation research director Caroline Frederickson said productivity gains do not automatically lead to higher wages or better jobs, and urged research into adoption and its effects in Ireland.

Why it matters

The testimony links two questions that are often argued separately: whose work is used to build AI, and who benefits when AI changes how work is done. For artists, the issue is not only whether a model can produce an image or text, but whether creators can find out how their work was used and seek meaningful redress.

For workers more broadly, the committee heard that higher productivity does not guarantee better pay or conditions. That makes the proposed tracking of adoption and outcomes more than a statistics exercise. Without it, claims about AI’s effects risk being measured mainly by the organisations adopting it.

Our read

This is a substantial policy discussion, not a verdict on the legality of AI training. The useful test for Ireland is whether testimony leads to clear rules, accessible routes to recourse and evidence about who gains from adoption. “We should study this” is a start; it is not, on its own, a remedy.

What to watch

  • Whether the committee recommends specific routes to recourse or compensation for creators.
  • Whether Ireland adopts the proposed research into workplace AI use and outcomes.
  • Whether public bodies set rules for using AI-generated material in place of commissioned creative work.

Discussion spark: Should Ireland require AI developers and public bodies to provide creators with a route to challenge the use of their work, or would that risk restricting legitimate AI use before the rules are clear?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.