Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million over Facebook’s access to photos and videos on Android phones without what the regulator considered informed consent. The decision affects about 20 million users in Italy and orders Meta to change how the feature is presented and enabled.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The Italian authority, Garante, says Facebook’s “Get tips from your gallery while browsing Facebook” feature was enabled by default. It found that a broad permission request and generic notice did not clearly tell users that Facebook would access their device’s photo gallery to offer suggestions. The feature was introduced in 2023, according to Verdict.
Garante ordered Meta to keep the feature disabled by default, obtain explicit, separate consent and explain how users can turn it off. Verdict says Meta must report compliance initiatives within 30 days and provide details of changes within 90 days. If it does not comply within 60 days, the feature must be disabled for users without valid consent. PetaPixel reports that Meta disputes the regulator’s assessment and plans to appeal.
Why it matters
This is a dispute about access to personal photos on a phone, not a finding that those photos were used to train AI. Verdict says the regulator’s procedure did not examine AI training; the authority is separately assessing a newer feature that processes gallery content using cloud technology. Those distinctions matter when a privacy ruling is being discussed alongside AI.
The immediate practical issue is consent: a permission covering several functions may not clearly tell people what a particular feature does. The regulator’s ruling and required changes could affect how Meta offers gallery suggestions to users in Italy, while the appeal may challenge both the decision and the size of the penalty.
Our read
A phone permission is not a blank cheque for every use an app can dream up. Garante’s decision puts the spotlight on whether users were told plainly what gallery access enabled, and whether a default-on feature can earn meaningful consent. Meta’s appeal means the legal dispute is not over, but the order gives the company concrete changes and deadlines to address.
What to watch
- Whether Meta files an appeal and what grounds it gives.
- Whether Garante confirms that Meta has met the consent and default-setting requirements.
- What the authority says about its separate assessment of the newer cloud-based gallery feature.
Discussion spark: When an app asks for access to your photos, should one permission cover several features, or should each use require its own clear consent?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (16 November 2026, 09:19 UTC)
- Source update (16 November 2026, 09:19 UTC)
- Jensen Huang ‘plotting Nvidia return’ as petition tops 175,000 signatures – The Independent (16 November 2026, 09:19 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.