Luxury brands are making visible human labour part of the pitch for their campaigns as AI-generated imagery becomes more common. The trend ranges from Prada’s hand-drawn holiday animation to a Dior campaign now facing unconfirmed online speculation about how it was made.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The National describes this deliberate display of craft as “effort signalling”: a way to make time, skill and human input part of a product’s appeal. Prada’s 2026 holiday films use hand-drawn characters created by veteran animator John Pomeroy, woven into live-action scenes.
The article points to other examples, including Loewe’s commission of about 2,000 individual watercolour paintings for an animated film, and hand-drawn or artist-led work from Hermès, Chanel and Oribe. It also describes past criticism of AI-generated promotional imagery from Valentino and Gucci. Dior’s illustrated Christmas campaign has prompted online speculation about possible AI involvement, but the article does not establish that AI was used.
Why it matters
For luxury brands, the story is not simply whether a campaign was made by hand or with software. Customers are being asked to pay for craftsmanship and creative skill, so showing how work was made can help justify that promise. The same visibility also invites scrutiny: claims about human effort need to match the finished work.
AI is not the only possible source of unease. The National says audiences’ concern includes whether brands are replacing human creative work while continuing to charge luxury prices. In that setting, a glimpse of the process becomes part of the product’s story, not just a making-of extra.
Our read
“Effort signalling” neatly captures a real marketing turn: when synthetic imagery is quick to produce, visible time and skill can become a point of distinction. But the standard should be honest disclosure, not a guessing game built from a few odd-looking frames. Dior’s campaign remains a case of online speculation in this account, not proof of AI use.
What to watch
- Whether brands explain how AI or other digital tools were used in campaign work.
- Whether audiences reward visible craft, or mainly expect clear disclosure.
- Whether the speculation around Dior’s campaign is answered with evidence from the brand or its collaborators.
Discussion spark: Should luxury brands have to disclose when AI contributes to campaign imagery, or is showing the creative process enough?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (13 November 2026, 11:29 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.