More than 50 organisations and individuals have submitted friend-of-the-court briefs in the copyright case against OpenAI, according to Publishing Perspectives. The filings lay out sharply different views on whether AI training can qualify as fair use, and the next round is due on 6 November.
OpenAI Watch analysis
What happened
Publishing Perspectives editor-in-chief Andrew Richard Albanese says 51 amicus briefs are now before the judge. The article describes arguments from authors and publishers that training on copyrighted work can harm creators and markets, alongside arguments that broad fair-use protections support research, public knowledge and new forms of expression.
The article’s stated breakdown is internally inconsistent: it gives 26 briefs supporting plaintiffs, 18 supporting defendants and eight neutral, figures that add up to 52 rather than 51. It also says the final round of briefs is due on 6 November, after which oral arguments are to be scheduled.
Why it matters
The case is not just a yes-or-no contest over whether AI companies can train on copyrighted material. The briefs raise competing questions about creator compensation, licensing, fair use and whether outputs that compete with existing work should affect the legal analysis. Those are arguments from parties and interested groups, not findings by the court.
Our read
The breadth of the filings makes this a useful snapshot of the dispute’s fault lines, but the tally needs tidying before anyone treats its exact breakdown as settled. The useful takeaway is the range of positions now in front of the judge, not a winner declared by the brief-counting department.
What to watch
- The final briefs due on 6 November.
- When the court schedules oral arguments.
- Whether the judge distinguishes model training, the acquisition of training material and AI-generated outputs.
Discussion spark: Should copyright law treat AI training as fair use by default, or should developers need permission when licensing is practical?
Sources and evidence
OpenAI Watch is independently operated by WittyWires. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or operated by OpenAI.