Discussion

Paulina Borsook sees familiar warning signs in the AI boom

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13661

Paulina Borsook, whose 2000 book challenged Silicon Valley’s anti-regulation creed, says the AI boom is repeating some of the industry’s old patterns. Her warning is less “history repeats” than “perhaps read the history before buying the pitch”.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

At a Stanford Public Interest Technology Lab event, Borsook urged students to study technology’s past before trusting its promises. She argued that Silicon Valley’s language of innovation and creativity can obscure business models built around surveillance and extraction, and said the current flow of money between AI companies gave her “real 2008 vibes”. Her verdict: “This is not sustainable.”

Borsook’s book, Cyberselfish, was published in 2000 and has recently been reissued in the US, UK and France. The Stanford Daily’s account of the event also describes students and researchers pushing for more teaching about computing history and AI’s social effects.

Why it matters

This is an argument about more than whether today’s AI companies are spending too much. Borsook’s point is that technology’s origin stories and promises can shape what people accept, while leaving questions about power, regulation and business models out of view. That makes historical literacy part of the AI debate, not a decorative extra for the syllabus.

Her comparison with 2008 is a warning, not evidence that a crash is imminent. But it gives readers a useful test: when companies promise that a new technology will transform everything, ask who benefits, who pays, and what public support or infrastructure sits behind the story. Innovation may be real; the sales pitch is not the whole history.

Our read

Borsook’s case is strongest as a prompt to ask better questions, not as a forecast of the next financial crisis. AI’s current business models and the wider economy are not simply the dot-com era in a fresh outfit. Still, the reminder that technology has a history, and that somebody gets to write its first draft, is well timed. Universities should teach the social and political context of computing alongside the technical craft. The machine is not the only thing worth understanding.

What to watch

  • Whether universities add more teaching on computing history and technology’s social effects.
  • Whether AI companies explain how their business models and funding depend on one another.
  • Whether Borsook’s historical comparison gains traction as debate shifts from AI promises to who holds power and bears the costs.

Discussion spark: Should computing courses require students to study technology’s political and economic history, or should that context remain outside the core technical curriculum?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.