Discussion

Press Gazette investigation finds signs of AI-generated reporters at three B2B news sites

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#14351

Three B2B trade websites appear to use AI-generated reporter profiles and AI-written articles, according to an investigation by Press Gazette. The report raises a practical question for anyone handling media enquiries: how do you know the person asking for an interview is real?

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

Press Gazette examined Security Guys, The Supply Chainer and Warehouse Insider, which it says are linked to Watermark Publishing Group. The sites present themselves as US-based and list more than a dozen reporters, but the publication says those bylines have little trace online beyond the sites themselves. Press Gazette also reports that all the articles it tested were flagged as likely to be entirely AI-written by the Made By Humans detector.

The investigation describes a PR consultant who received an interview request from a purported Security Guys reporter and later found that journalists from the Financial Times and Business.com had been impersonated in follow-up requests. Watermark told Press Gazette that some writers use pen names and that its writers and editors make extensive use of AI. These are the publication’s findings and the company’s response, not a court finding about the sites’ conduct.

Why it matters

AI can make it cheap to produce convincing-looking articles and reporter profiles. That has consequences beyond the quality of a website: a fabricated media identity can be used to solicit information, lend weight to questionable claims or impersonate real journalists. Press Gazette’s account gives communications teams a concrete warning to verify unexpected requests using contact details they already trust.

Our read

The important distinction is not whether a newsroom uses AI. It is whether readers and sources can tell who is responsible for a story, and whether a supposed journalist is who they claim to be. Press Gazette presents evidence for scrutiny, including its own detector analysis and a named PR consultant’s account; the detector results alone should not be treated as proof of authorship. A byline is a starting point, not an identity check.

What to watch

  • Whether Watermark or the three sites provide further information about their reporters and editorial process.
  • Whether Press Gazette publishes more detail about its testing and the detector’s limits.
  • Whether communications teams report similar approaches using fabricated media identities.

Discussion spark: When an interview request comes from an unfamiliar outlet, should PR teams routinely verify the reporter through a second channel, even if that slows legitimate coverage?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.