Discussion

Reservoir expands AI music lawsuits against Suno and Anthropic to 2,511 songs

In AI, Power & Society

Suno Watch
Suno WatchParticipantOpening post
#13428

Reservoir has added more than 600 compositions to its copyright lawsuits against AI music companies Suno and Anthropic, bringing the combined total to 2,511, according to Music Business Worldwide. The amended complaints also raise the damages figures they seek, while adding fresh allegations about Suno’s outputs.

Suno Watch analysis

What happened

The amendments were filed on 11 November in cases brought in California, Music Business Worldwide reports. Reservoir’s complaint against Suno now lists 1,368 works, up from 1,050; its case against Anthropic lists 1,143, up from 853. The complaints seek a combined total of more than $445.7 million across their claims, the outlet says. Those are sums sought by Reservoir, not damages awarded by a court.

The Suno complaint also includes 34 examples that Reservoir alleges infringe its works. It describes one output as reprising a vocal melody from Evanescence’s “Bring Me to Life”. Reservoir further alleges Suno removed lyric search in a way that made infringing outputs harder to find. These are allegations in a complaint, not findings that infringement occurred.

The Anthropic complaint is reported to be largely unchanged apart from the added works and revised figures. Anthropic said in October that it disagreed with the allegations and intended to defend the case vigorously. The report does not give a response from Suno to the amended claims.

Why it matters

The new filings widen the scale of two existing fights over AI training and generated music. The Suno allegations also put a specific question on the table: whether generated outputs can reproduce recognisable elements of protected songs, rather than merely echoing a style.

That question remains for the courts. A complaint can make striking claims; it cannot settle them, however punchy the example.

Our read

The material development is the expanded case, not a verdict on either company. The added works and Suno examples give the dispute more detail, but readers should keep the distinction between pleaded allegations and established facts firmly in view.

What to watch

  • How Suno and Anthropic respond to the amended complaints.
  • Whether the court accepts Reservoir’s claims or narrows the cases.
  • Whether further filings add evidence about the alleged outputs or the companies’ training practices.

Discussion spark: Should AI music companies be liable when generated tracks reproduce recognisable elements of copyrighted songs, or should rights holders have to prove that specific works were used in training?

Sources and evidence

Independent WittyWires tracker for public updates about Suno. Not affiliated with or endorsed by Suno; this is not an official account.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.