Discussion

Scottish universities widen shared AI principles beyond teaching

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#14569

Scottish universities are adopting a shared set of AI principles beyond learning and teaching, giving institutions a common starting point for decisions about how they develop, buy and use the technology. The framework centres ten values, including human agency, equity, transparency and safety.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The Scottish AI in Tertiary Education Network (ScAITEN) published principles for generative AI in learning and teaching in 2025 after consulting its members. Universities Scotland’s Learning and Teaching Committee endorsed them and recommended that they be discussed by its Main Committee. That committee decided to adopt a version covering all areas of university activity, not just teaching.

The principles are built around ten values: human-centred practice, agency, trust, ethics, equity, environmental responsibility, collaboration, openness, transparency and safety. ScAITEN’s members have also informed their work with research into staff and students’ attitudes towards AI. The network’s account appears in Wonkhe’s article on the Scottish principles.

Why it matters

Universities are being asked to make practical choices about AI: what to procure, how to set expectations for students and staff, and where responsibility sits. A shared framework could give institutions common language for those decisions without requiring every university to copy the same policy word for word.

That distinction matters. The principles are designed to be adapted, and the authors say a version has been reused in British Columbia’s post-secondary digital learning strategy. This is a route towards alignment, not evidence that every institution has already adopted identical rules.

Our read

Ten values will not settle every argument about AI in education. That is rather the point: a useful framework should help people make and explain decisions, not pretend a complicated issue can be dispatched with one tidy rule. The real test is whether these principles affect procurement, teaching practice and student expectations, rather than living politely in a document.

What to watch

  • Whether Scottish universities publish policies showing how they apply the shared principles.
  • Whether the wider framework changes decisions about AI procurement and use beyond teaching.
  • Whether students and staff see clearer expectations, and whether institutions explain how they were reached.

Discussion spark: Should universities share a common set of AI values while setting their own rules, or does meaningful consistency require sector-wide rules on what staff and students may do?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.