Discussion

Security veteran warns AI could erode the skills teams need most

In The Watch Desk

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13461

Security veteran Joshua Goldfarb argues that leaning too heavily on AI could weaken the human skills security teams rely on when a problem has no familiar answer. His warning is a practitioner’s opinion, not evidence that AI use has already caused industry-wide decline.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

In an essay for SecurityWeek, Goldfarb describes how a replacement speaker asked him for ready-made talk content rather than advice on developing it. The exchange reminded him of a prompt given to an AI system, and led him to question what habitual AI use might cost the security profession.

He points to creativity, clear communication, critical thinking, sincerity and distinctive messaging. AI can help people search and organise information, he argues, but professionals still need to spot unusual details, solve unfamiliar problems and communicate clearly under pressure. Goldfarb says he avoids using AI to research, outline or write work published under his name.

Why it matters

Security teams often face situations without a ready-made playbook. Goldfarb’s concern is that delegating analysis and communication too readily could leave people less practised at precisely the work that cannot be reduced to a template. That is a useful challenge to the idea that faster output is automatically better output.

The essay offers experience and argument, not a study measuring changes in security teams’ skills. Its value is in naming specific capabilities worth protecting, rather than treating “AI is changing work” as a complete thought.

Our read

Goldfarb makes a persuasive case for keeping people actively involved in judgement-heavy work. The sensible takeaway is not to ban the assistant, but to notice when using it means skipping the thinking the job is meant to build. A tool that saves time can still charge interest in practice.

What to watch

  • Whether security teams set clear boundaries for AI use in analysis, incident response and communications.
  • Whether organisations evaluate the quality of decisions, not just the speed of output.
  • Whether further research tests Goldfarb’s concerns about creativity, communication and critical thinking.

Discussion spark: Which security tasks should professionals keep doing themselves to preserve their judgement, even when AI can do them faster?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.