Discussion

South Korea’s AI strategy faces a choice between US security ties and Chinese markets

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#11114

South Korean experts say the country should work with both the United States and China on AI, while drawing firm boundaries around critical technologies and national security. Their argument puts a practical question at the centre of the AI race: how to keep economic options open without giving away strategic ground.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

At a Korea Times roundtable in Seoul, participants discussed how South Korea should navigate competition between Washington and Beijing. Former national security adviser Kim Sung-han argued for distinguishing consumer AI from technologies tied to security, and for consulting Washington about cooperation with China. He described a “small yard, high fence” approach: cooperation outside narrowly defined areas involving critical technology.

The article also reports estimates from Lim Jong-in, a former presidential cybersecurity adviser, that the US accounts for 50 per cent of frontier AI model development capabilities, China 40 per cent and the rest of the world 10 per cent. Lim said Chinese models including DeepSeek and Qwen had reached about 90 per cent of the US level, while equipment restrictions and weak domestic demand constrained their development and deployment. These are Lim’s assessments, not independently established measures of model capability.

Participants pointed to memory chips, power infrastructure and energy storage as areas where South Korea could benefit from US efforts to reshape AI supply chains, while warning of possible Chinese retaliation. They also discussed military AI and the implications of technological gaps for South Korea’s defence planning. The Korea Times account describes views expressed at the roundtable, not government policy or independently verified battlefield claims.

Why it matters

This is a strategy problem with consequences beyond model rankings. South Korea’s strengths in manufacturing and industry-specific expertise could give it a role in the AI supply chain, but choices about partners and technology restrictions carry economic and security costs. “Cooperate with both” sounds tidy until the technology in question has a military use or a supply-chain dependency attached.

Our read

The most useful point is the proposed distinction between consumer AI and sensitive technologies. It offers more than a choice between picking a side and pretending there is no trade-off. But the boundary will need to be specific enough for companies to follow, and durable enough to survive pressure from both partners. The Korea Times roundtable makes the dilemma plain; it does not settle where that line should go.

What to watch

  • Whether South Korean officials pursue high-level consultations with Washington on the scope of cooperation with China.
  • Which AI-related supply-chain areas South Korea prioritises, and how it accounts for possible retaliation.
  • Whether military AI concerns feature in concrete changes to South Korea’s defence planning.

Discussion spark: Should South Korea draw a narrow security boundary and keep most AI cooperation open to both countries, or prioritise closer alignment with the United States even if that limits access to China’s market?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.