Discussion

SSE legal director’s four-question test puts AI behind the work

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#9840

Before putting AI into legal work, Emily Bull’s test is to ask whether the task should be eliminated, enabled for someone else, engineered into a better process or left to a lawyer’s expertise. The SSE legal director says teams can start with a small, real problem and learn by doing, rather than waiting for a perfect transformation plan.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

In an interview with Artificial Lawyer, Bull described applying the “Four Es” while redesigning legal delivery and leading SSE Legal’s work on AI adoption and governance. She says her team began with work already coming through the door, using technology it already had access to. Meeting notes were one useful starting point for her; first-pass reviews of property titles and land agreements are among the potential AI uses she sees in property and energy legal work.

Bull’s dividing line is accountability: AI can help lawyers reach a judgement more efficiently, but it cannot take responsibility for the decision or its wider commercial context. She also warns that relying on AI could quietly weaken people’s verification skills, particularly if junior lawyers lose work that once helped them develop judgement.

Why it matters

The framework starts with the work, not the tool. That is a practical distinction for teams facing pressure to adopt AI: some tasks may disappear, move to someone better placed to do them, or need a redesigned process before software enters the picture. “Use AI” is not, by itself, a plan for improving legal services.

Bull’s concerns also point to a less obvious implementation challenge. If AI takes over routine work, organisations still need deliberate ways for junior lawyers to practise checking, questioning and developing sound judgement. Faster output is not much of a bargain if the people responsible for reviewing it lose the skills that review requires.

Our read

The Four Es make a useful first conversation, not a magic formula. Starting small with existing tools can build momentum, as Bull argues, provided that teams also make verification and human accountability part of the work from the start. Otherwise, they may simply automate a bad process and give its errors a head start.

What to watch

  • Whether legal teams use the Four Es to assess work before choosing AI tools.
  • How organisations build verification and judgement into AI-assisted work, especially for junior lawyers.
  • Whether reported deployments show improvements to service and stakeholder experience, not just faster document handling.

Discussion spark: If AI removes routine legal tasks, who should be responsible for ensuring junior lawyers still get the practice needed to develop judgement?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.