The New York Times has added an AI tool that suggests how to modify its recipes, including ingredient substitutions such as using spinach instead of chard. For now, it is available to Cooking subscribers on iOS, with a wider rollout planned.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The tool is being introduced gradually so the Times can monitor its speed and how people use it. The newspaper’s cooking staff say they spent time evaluating answers so they would align with the publication’s culinary standards. Earlier AI features in the app converted measurements and adjusted recipes to serve more or fewer people.
The new feature is optional to use, but the Times has not offered a way to switch it off entirely, according to the account. Nieman Lab reports that some readers objected to the addition, while others welcomed help with dietary substitutions. Its article describes comments on the Times’ announcement, not a representative survey of subscribers.
Why it matters
Recipe substitutions are not a cosmetic flourish: ingredients can change cooking times, texture and flavour. The Times is putting AI into a practical decision cooks make mid-recipe, while asking users to trust that its suggestions reflect editorial expertise. That is a more specific test than asking a chatbot to improvise dinner, but a poor substitution can still leave someone with a disappointing meal.
The launch also puts a familiar product question on the table: when does an optional convenience improve a trusted service, and when does adding AI make the service feel less like itself?
Our read
A recipe-modification tool has a plausible job to do, especially for people navigating dietary needs or an empty fridge. The Times says its cooking staff evaluated the answers, which is relevant groundwork, not a guarantee that every suggestion will work in every kitchen. We would judge it by the quality of the substitutions and the control users have over the feature, not by the novelty of the label.
What to watch
- Whether the feature expands beyond iOS subscribers.
- How well its substitutions handle cooking method, timing and dietary needs.
- Whether the Times adds a setting to disable the feature altogether.
Discussion spark: Should a trusted recipe publisher use AI to suggest ingredient swaps, or does that kind of advice need to stay with its human cooking editors?
Sources and evidence
- The New York Times is adding more AI features to its Cooking app, and users aren’t thrilled – Nieman Lab (28 October 2026, 18:54 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.