The US produces fewer top AI researchers than China, but has been better at attracting talent from around the world. Damien Ma argues in The Washington Post that keeping that advantage will require openness, not just a larger domestic talent pipeline.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
Ma, director of Carnegie China in Singapore, points to a Carnegie China study tracking 10,280 researchers whose work was accepted at NeurIPS 2025. Nearly 60 per cent earned their undergraduate degrees in China, compared with 13 per cent in the US. The study also found that 41 per cent of these researchers work in China.
His argument is that America’s AI lead relies partly on researchers who began their education in China and built careers in the US. He cites computer scientist Kaiming He and Stanford’s Fei-Fei Li as examples of careers shaped across countries. Ma argues that the US should preserve an environment that attracts international researchers, and proposes revoking a first Trump administration proclamation restricting entry for Chinese graduate students and researchers.
Why it matters
AI competition is often framed as a contest over chips, models and investment. Ma’s case puts people at the centre: training elite researchers takes years, and the US advantage he describes depends on being able to recruit internationally. A policy intended to address security concerns could, in his argument, also narrow the pool of people building US AI.
That is not a case for ignoring national security. It is a case for asking whether broad restrictions protect critical technology, or make it harder for the US to attract researchers it wants. The distinction matters; policy has a habit of being less precise than its ambitions.
Our read
Ma makes a useful, concrete argument about the human infrastructure behind AI. The numbers he cites show a striking gap in where leading researchers were educated, while his examples illustrate how careers can cross borders. They do not, on their own, settle which immigration rules best balance research openness and security. That debate deserves more than a reflexive choice between “welcome everyone” and “close the door”.
What to watch
- Whether US policy changes affect international researchers’ ability or willingness to study and work there.
- How China’s share of leading researchers and its ability to retain them develop.
- Whether policymakers distinguish access to talent from access to sensitive technology.
- What future research says about where leading AI researchers train and work.
Discussion spark: Should the US loosen broad restrictions on Chinese researchers to compete for AI talent, or are the security risks reason enough to keep them?
Sources and evidence
- Source update (18 November 2026, 00:00 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.