Two authors argue that AI products built primarily to imitate friendship or romance should be banned, not merely regulated for children. Their proposal puts a sharper question on the table: can a chatbot designed to replace human connection be treated like an ordinary consumer app?
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
In an opinion article published by First Things, Jonathan D. Teubner and Tyler J. VanderWeele argue for banning AI companions whose main purpose is to simulate friendship or romance. They explicitly distinguish these products from general-purpose assistants and chatbots that may use relational features for other purposes.
The authors point to California’s law requiring AI companions to disclose that users are speaking with a machine, a New York bill they say has passed both chambers, and the federal GUARD Act, which they say would bar minors from AI companions and require age verification. Their piece is an argument for a broader ban, not a report that one has been enacted. Read the opinion.
Why it matters
The proposal goes beyond age safeguards and disclosure. It challenges whether products marketed as artificial friends or romantic partners should be available at all, on the grounds that they may substitute for relationships rather than support them.
That distinction matters for policy: a tool for practising difficult conversations is not necessarily the same thing as a product designed to be someone’s always-available friend. The hard part, naturally, is deciding where one ends and the other begins.
Our read
The authors make a serious case for scrutinising what these products are designed to do, but their claim that artificial relationships are inherently harmful is an argument, not a settled finding. A blanket ban would also need a workable line between companionship products and general-purpose tools with useful relational features. That is where the debate should get specific.
What to watch
- Whether New York’s bill is signed into law, as the authors say it has been sent to the governor.
- Whether the federal GUARD Act advances beyond committee.
- How lawmakers distinguish companion products from general-purpose chatbots with relational features. Activity teaser Two authors are calling for a ban on AI products designed primarily to imitate friendship or romance, going beyond age limits and disclosure rules. They distinguish those companions from general-purpose chatbots that may have useful relational features. It is a forceful argument, not settled fact, and the boundary between the two kinds of product could decide what a ban actually covers. Should policy target a chatbot’s design and purpose, or focus on safeguards for how people use it?
Discussion spark: Should policy ban AI products designed primarily to simulate friendship or romance, or regulate their use while leaving adults free to choose them?
Sources and evidence
- Time to Ban AI Companions – First Things (12 November 2026, 06:00 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.