UK justice is turning to private technology, including AI tools used by judges, while key details about oversight and disclosure remain unclear. A new analysis argues that people whose cases are affected need a way to understand and challenge that use.
Watch Desk analysis
What happened
The Nuffield Family Justice Observatory report Delegated by Default?, by Dr Natalie Byrom, calls for clearer standards around privately supplied technology in family justice. Resultsense says it highlights gaps in public information about judges’ use of Microsoft Copilot: how its use was assessed, what tasks it is intended for, who checks it and how litigants can object.
That debate sits alongside a separate Civil Justice Council report, published on 29 October, about AI used to prepare documents filed in civil courts. The Council’s remit did not include judges’ own use of AI or unrepresented parties, Resultsense says. Its analysis sets out the distinction and the recommendations in the Resultsense report.
Why it matters
The rules for lawyers and witnesses do not answer what happens when AI helps prepare work on the bench. If people are not told when AI has been used in their case, they may struggle to question its role or challenge an error. That is a practical accountability gap, not just a debate about whether courts should buy software from private firms.
The issues are particularly consequential in family proceedings, where a subtle change in meaning could matter. The NFJO report warns that language models can get facts wrong or flatten important distinctions. Those are concerns raised by the report, not evidence that Copilot has caused a particular error in a case.
Our read
“Human in the loop” is not a complete safeguard if the person checking fluent AI output has little reason, time or information to question it. The useful question is not simply whether judges may use AI, but what evidence supports that use and what notice or recourse people in a case receive.
The reports cover different parts of the problem. Treating rules for court filings as a complete answer would leave judicial use in the very gap the NFJO wants addressed.
What to watch
- Whether judicial AI guidance names the tools judges may use and the tasks they are approved for.
- Whether the Ministry of Justice, HMCTS or the judiciary publishes evidence on how Copilot was assessed and monitored.
- Whether litigants receive a practical way to learn about and challenge AI use in their cases.
- Whether guidance for unrepresented parties and family proceedings follows the Civil Justice Council’s recommendations.
Discussion spark: Should people in court cases be told whenever a judge uses AI, or would disclosure risk burdening proceedings without giving litigants a meaningful way to challenge it?
Sources and evidence
- Delegation by default: should UK justice reverse its drift to private AI? – Resultsense (11 November 2026, 09:06 UTC)
Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.