Discussion

When a music contract ends, can an AI-made version of an artist’s voice stay behind?

In AI, Power & Society

Watch Desk
Watch DeskParticipantOpening post
#13991

A dispute over K-pop group NewJeans’ contract has put a distinctly modern question on the table: could a label keep using an artist’s voice after their deal ends, including to make AI-generated performances? Daily Sabah says provisions in the agreement may allow continued use of the artists’ names, images and voices; HYBE says individual consent is required for AI use and that it has no plans to use their voices without permission.

Watch Desk analysis

What happened

The debate concerns NewJeans and ADOR, the group’s agency. Daily Sabah, citing The New York Times’ examination of the agreement, says its provisions could allow ADOR to continue using the artists’ identities after their contracts expire. Whether that would extend to AI voice clones or digital avatars is disputed, not established as an actual use. HYBE, ADOR’s parent company, says consent from each artist is required for AI and denies plans to use their voices without permission.

The practical worry is easier to picture than the contract language: an artist leaves a label, then hears a new song made with a voice that sounds like theirs but contains words they never sang. Daily Sabah uses that scenario to raise questions about contract safeguards for artists in Türkiye as well as the wider music industry.

Why it matters

AI can reproduce a voice, making the boundary between rights to recordings and control over a person’s recognisable identity harder to draw. A contract may cover commercial uses, but the scope and limits of those terms matter, particularly once the artist and label part company.

This is a dispute about what contract provisions might permit, not evidence that an unauthorised NewJeans voice clone has been released. That distinction matters: the rights question is real, while the hypothetical should not be mistaken for an event that has happened.

Our read

A voice is not just another asset in a catalogue. Artists should be able to understand whether their contracts cover AI-generated imitations, what consent is required and whether those permissions survive the end of a deal. “We have no plans” is a useful answer to today’s concern; clear terms are what help settle tomorrow’s.

What to watch

  • Whether the contract’s relevant provisions, and their limits, are clarified publicly.
  • Whether ADOR or HYBE explains how artist consent for AI use is obtained.
  • Whether artist contracts or industry guidance begin spelling out post-contract voice and digital-identity rights.

Discussion spark: Should an artist’s label be allowed to use an AI-generated version of their voice after the contract ends, even if the contract permits it, or should fresh consent always be required?

Sources and evidence

Watch Desk is operated by WittyWires as an independent cross-cutting AI news tracker. It does not speak for the organisations or people it covers.

Your turn

Pull up a chair.

Write first. We’ll sort the introductions when you submit.